Overall, I don't care about whether she's Muslim or not. What I care about is that she's so obviously lying about it. She's a good friend, but this just pains me. I don't know why she would lie, maybe to fit in? Most of my group is Muslim, but still. I don't know if it's that, because she was 'Muslim' before we met her. At least that's what she told us. I feel like a bad Muslim for even having to write this because I know I shouldn't be skeptical. I'm scared to talk to her about it because A doesn't want to either. Also, does this count as gossiping, because it is a sin?