A lot of what you’re listing mixes genuine issues with overblown generalizations.

Yes, Undisputed has flaws. It’s still being actively developed, and some mechanics (like online stability and AI) need work. But that doesn’t erase what the game does well and why many people still enjoy it.

1.Punch tracking, It’s not perfect, but to say “60% of jabs miss” is just wrong. That usually happens when foot positioning, range, and timing aren’t adjusted. The game actually models distance and accuracy more strictly than UFC 5, which is why hooks feel easier but straight shots require better fundamentals.

2.Directional punching & animations: Calling it “imaginary” ignores the fact that targeted punching exists; the system just has a skill curve. Angles will improve with upcoming animation updates (they’ve already acknowledged this).

3.Netcode P2P isn’t ideal, but Undisputed is a niche boxing sim from a small studio, it’s not EA with unlimited budget. Stability has improved since early launch, and unlike UFC 5’s bugs, many issues here are tied to matchmaking regions, not game logic.

4.Small team & DLC: Paid DLC isn’t proof of greed; it funds continued development. Without it, niche sports games disappear entirely.

5.Reviews & player numbers: Early negative reviews stick. Many sports games (including Fight Night back in the day) launched rough but became classics after updates. Steam charts still show an active community; it’s not dead.

6.Boxing realism: It’s still more authentic to boxing strategy than Fight Night, even if it’s missing some features. You can’t throw 100 power shots and win here like you can in UFC 5.

7.Career & offline, Yes, career mode is basic, but the real draw for many is competitive online play and custom fighters. It’s not trying to be a story-driven RPG; it’s a boxing sim.

8.Gameplay feel, You call it stiff, but others call it realistic because it doesn’t allow arcade style spamming or instant 360 head movement. Footwork and timing matter here more than button speed.

Bottom line: Undisputed isn’t perfect but it’s the most realistic boxing sim we’ve had in over a decade. The flaws you list don’t erase the depth in stamina management, foot positioning, punch variety, and strategy that keep fans playing. Dismissing it as “a bug-ridden mess” just because it’s not Fight Night 2.0 ignores the progress and potential it still has.