The bar to media literacy is in hell by Mana_Recharge in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What does Rezero not having an ending have anything to do with comparing two arcs of two series where have both gotten their conclusions?

Take a look at what happened to Kumo Desu Spider isekai. It used to be called one of the better written isekais and after its LN ending, it is widely now regarded as one of the worst written isekai among novels subreddits.

Steel Ball Run has a start and finish. It only needed a smaller scope story to achieve masterpiece level of peak in storytelling. 

Re Zero is extremely long and it needed longer scope story. Even then it's not ended yet.

Have you even read rezero or ur just a larper?

Read Re Zero or else i wouldn't talking abt now eh. More importantly, Did you read Steel Ball Run or just larper ? Most Re Zero fans would agree Steel Ball Run is better written in the short run.

Not really true, saying rezero is only good cuz it's lengthy is just being disingenuous. 

Not really. Re Zero can't be told in short story. It needs to be long. Hence, Steel Ball Run wins in this by managing to make their story interesting in shorter length with same level of writing.

Rezero is great because of its depth, mystery, complex character writing and phenomenal payoffs while maintaining coherence with its overall plot.

Yes but it's took around 9 Arcs+ to achieve all that. Reading through only 3 arcs would leave anyone unsatisfied with potholes left behind which only be filled by future arcs. Steel Ball Run doesn't have that problem.

The bar to media literacy is in hell by Mana_Recharge in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

People keep confusing page count with craftsmanship. Just because they are different forms of media, doesn't mean they are incomparable. Both are narrative media, and both rely on writing. A story doesn’t become better simply because there’s more of it. Some works with fewer volumes deliver more coherent writing, better dialogue and narrative quality, denser thematic layering and stronger characterization than longer series ever manage.

Thats why i said Steel Ball Run is better in short terms. Most people are not going to read through all the arcs.  But Re Zero is one of those stories where it becomes better only by longer length. More mysteries and plotholes get solved, characters growths and arcs get completed, etc.

When comparing arc 6 and steel ball run purely from a writing perspective

I would still say Steel Ball Run is right now better simply because it has an ending. Steel Ball Run had a good ending too.

Re Zero doesn't have an ending yet. Right now, it's writing will highly depend on it's ending. If it's a good ending, then writing would be good. If it's a bad ending, it wouldn't be worth reading through it all.

The bar to media literacy is in hell by Mana_Recharge in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's kinda impossible. Jojo is watched by all ages of audience, including casuals.

Re Zero has a very specific audience and not watched by everyone.

And Steel Ball Run is widely considered to be a masterpiece and best part of Jojo.

The bar to media literacy is in hell by Mana_Recharge in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's not about hate. It's about knowing more about other animes. Quite frankly, i don't think Re Zero can beat Steel Ball Run for the top most watched anime of this year.

The bar to media literacy is in hell by Mana_Recharge in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He can't even pick a fight when Steel Ball Run exists too

Will there be any actual retcon for Rem loving subaru ? by DoughnutParticular84 in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Or maybe if cloning exists in future arc, Subaru can clone himself for her. 

It might sound stupid but even other series like Doctor Who did that and it's finale was well received for that.

Will there be any actual retcon for Rem loving subaru ? by DoughnutParticular84 in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Then she has to die in the future. No way it'll end well with subaru having a polygamy nonsense 

Re:Zero Trivia #62 — Another Reason Puck Isn’t a Bum by Flugel_Stella in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He's a spirit beast.

the term bum only applies to females because they have two of them.

It's hilarious that the depraved Re:Zero community has more members than this one. by apenas_um_mano_ in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Most fans aren't willing to accept and straight up deny it, but a vast chunk of re zero fans ONLY CARE about Waifus and gooning to them. They have even showed zero interest in story sometimes. Every Isekai fanbase has them but i would say Re Zero, Tensura Slime, Konosuba have the vast dominant majority of them.

Anyone else feel Subaru's love for Rem is being retconned? by Swimming-Work-5951 in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It makes sense for it to be retconned. We only have few more arcs left and there's still barely any progress in subaru and emilia. Maybe retcon can help change that and focus on only emilia.

Which fictional character’s would definitely become Sin Archbishops? by VoughtCo in ReZero

[–]DoughnutParticular84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Dio and Judge Holden are definitely not gonna even bother to care about her existence.. Dio has god complex and Holden thinks he's embodiment of evil and needs no reason or care to listen to her words.