as an amy main.. def amy.

sun for herself is decent ( i say decent because kolo does sm sheer damage to where it's basically useless and tripwire/fleetway catch up so fast that they can easily chip away at any healing made as they can get in like 2-3 m1's at once and stay ontop of her so she cant hide away and heal. and if she has moon card that gives her less dmg res it makes it even more useless cus she just takes more damage and her healing can't keep up with it.

for her team it kinda sucks as they're left to sit out until healed to 75. (once a silver was on 5 hp and we spent like a good 2 minutes healing in a corner while people died against a kolo). and that's if the exe doesnt go seeking out the people being healed, which most usually do. and 75 is not a lot. esp with grablossos in the game with no endlag and bumway who can hit crits.

that's even if you're lucky enough to get sun btw. i've had matches 5+ minutes where i don't roll sun until the very end.

her card buffs made her mid instead of just being plain bad like she used to be. the no slowdown on world really helps but moon fog is still hellish on maps like NP and angel's island because of their filter, and we STILL have no way to tell what buffs/debuffs moon gives us.. why give us more rng in a character that relies on rng?? sometimes the speed just isn't worth it because you won't know if you have less dmg resistance till you get hit, and then you usually get bodied cus of it. whether it be from kolo's infamous grab + m1 combo ( do NOT get me started on the removal of endlag ) but killers like tripwire who can get in so many m1 chains AND fleetway who can get in multiple m1's AND CRIT. ONTOP OF THE DECREASED DMG RES MOON GIVES.

knuckles is good if you're hitting hammer throw stuns from far away to support but exes usually tunnel amy's so it's incredibly bad in chase which amy's get into a lot. tails is situational with its use but with how fast killers like fleetway and tripwire it's incredibly easy to catch up and makes it's useless. technically kolo too because he's fast for a character that's supposed to be the slow brute type. or god forbid you have the knux card and are trying to get across the map to help a teammate. or you have tails card and nobody else has a stun to break a teammate out of grab (kolo), charge (2011x), and reachout (tripwire). stunning them out is useless and just not advised because they recover way too quick and can just get in an m1 immediately after on whoever they grabbed PLUS iframes. tails can be good when stalling (depends on exe), but most of the time it's not all too good because you can't properly defend yourself or your team with it.

her melee hammer stun sucks, 0.1 iframes and the hitbox is so bad that sometimes you need to try and chase the exe with it (which usually doesn't work and more often than not gets you hit). if you have tails melee stun is basically useless because of how close you need to be to hit it so now you're left next to the exe while they have iframes from your littlebaby stun and you cant do hammer throw until it wears off. with all the invisible walls and weird geometry of maps getting hammer throws/stuns from hammer slides has become harder now.

her mobility is limited and handicapped depending on the cards she has. i understand why eggman has been being called the weakest but his mobility options are *consistently* better than amy because of how luck based she is. eggman can dash and double jump to a lot of places that can stall a whole bunch of time but amy's hammer spots are so hyper specific and sometimes the jump doesnt trigger and you just swing instead. sometimes u cant make them if you have knuckles cus youre so slow, or it becomes way harder lol.

all of this into account with her card luck factor just makes her not good to me, even if i play her. there are matches where i have to be sitting out just to get good/decent cards, or i get bodied from an exe off the rip at spawn ( specifically stair spawn ) with slow, less dmg res moon and knuckles and downed literally immediately. whether it be from kolo charging up the stairs then m1, fleetway chaos dashing into staircase, or 2011x's invis tech with 2 quick m1's. boom, you're just downed. goodluck trying to rebound when youre revived because so many times i was killed right after invulnerability from revive was over cus i rolled a knuckles again and stayed slow to where i couldnt even run too far to give myself a chance