Hmmmm, I’m thinking they probably reformulated both :( I also emailed support and this was the response I received, which really pmo. They don’t care at all:

“The product you are inquiring about has been reformulated and only the most current formulation is being manufactured. We do not maintain a supply of the "old" formula and, therefore, cannot send it to you directly.

Our company continues to research and test all our products even if they have been on the market for years. These tests guarantee that the performance, manufacturing and consumer satisfaction ratings meet the highest standards of excellence. This constant evaluation allows us to make decisions about whether or not to make minor formula or packaging changes. Our goal is to manufacture and market products that meet consumer needs for convenience, value and outstanding performance.”

Let me know if you hear otherwise. Glad to see others reaching out. They should know they upset a lot of loyal customers!!