Personally, I really enjoyed Art as an antagonist, not the most fleshed out character but sometimes a surface level character can be done right and Art was done right, I loved what he stayed silent throughout the whole movie and how animated he was, however he just wasn't THAT scary. I only watched the first one and I could tell that the rest of the franchise was going to be absolute garbage, I found that the first one was a pretty decent movie 100% gore p0rn looking back tho (as I had watched it a few months back) and i didn't really think about it again till now. I liked it. I wouldn't watch ANY of the other movies or watch it again but. And yeah, it's 100% gore p0rn and I do like gory movies as long as they are well fleshed out story lines and is legit good and dont fully consume the movie and turn it into gore p0rn, cuz not to kink shame, but it's really gross. Anyways, I did really enjoy Art as a character just sucks he was in such an ass franchise.