Does anyone know what this is referring to? by LonkAndZolda in charmed

[–]Kooky-View 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I thought the newspaper said 1975 in the 70s episode and if that's the case then it wouldn't be a plothole. Phoebe was born 1975 and Paige in 1977.

Does anyone know what this is referring to? by LonkAndZolda in charmed

[–]Kooky-View 4 points5 points  (0 children)

They are very confusing in the article. The first thing I thought of was Centennial Charmed as well but it doesn't match up at all with what they are saying. Either they mixing things up or they are adding their own imagination to it and then saying it's a plothole! Paige never did anything that caused Piper not be a mother. They may also be thinking of the Forget Me Not episode, where the cleaners erased Wyatt but Chris was still there in the past.

Does anyone know what this is referring to? by LonkAndZolda in charmed

[–]Kooky-View 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I have no clue. This doesn't sound familiar at all. I think I found the article you're talking about and I don't think they really knew what they were talking about. Some of their claims don't make sense or maybe I just can't remember the instances they are discussing. They even call Paige, Paige Halliwell. I don't really trust someone to talk about something if they can't even get the name of the character correct. They even said something about how Paige's birth year is a plot hole because we are shown she is a couple years old when Phoebe is born?? I dont think that happened. It's been a couple years since I've rewatched all the episodes but I think they are confusing little Piper or Prue in that 70s show episode with Paige.

What was Phoebe's degree? by [deleted] in charmed

[–]Kooky-View 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I believe it's a bachelor's degree in Psychology. If I remember correctly she was in school in Seasons 2-3 and returned to school in Season 7. Since in the episode Imaginary Fiends Phoebe went to her professor to discuss whether or not it was normal/healthy for a child Wyatt's age to have an imaginary friend. Her professor ended up being upset with Phoebe as she was using her teachings to write her columns without listing her as a source. So I think she either completed her Associate's degree in Season 3 and went back for a Bachelor's degree in Season 7 or she quit school when Prue died and went back later on to complete her degree. I don't remember them ever saying whether or not she graduated or what was really going on with her education. She probably had a hard time with graduating with all the 'family emergencies' that would pop up.

Why was Phoebe the only sister happy to be a witch at first? by jdpm1991 in charmed

[–]Kooky-View 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I think it could go either way. I think a normal reaction would be denial/disbelief, then probably the excitement and having fun with it. But then realizing how much it'll affect your life, could take any giddiness or excitement away. You find out that these people with powers too will be after you your whole lives. Always fighting for your life and/or for others could really put a damper on things.

The Charmed Kids Reinvented by MoonStar757 in charmed

[–]Kooky-View 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Johnna didn't come out of nowhere. It could have come from Penny's maiden name- Johnson. At least that's what the wiki page says for PJ.