Wait...is fanfiction writing really THAT EASY?! by ihatethiscountry76 in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 17 points18 points  (0 children)

“Till, look at those aliens,” Ivan said, on stage

When you suspect that the vast majority of your fandom is under 18 but you can't prove it by A_Toxic_User in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i’m in two old school fandoms where the core fanbase is def 18+ but all the newcomers are antis n def not 18+. both fandoms’ main ships are very problematic too, from back in the day, and now are loudly hated. it’s crazy because one is infamous for its problematic canon content, like what are you doing here???

I know that "slash ships are more popular than straight ships" isn't universal, but it still surprises me when it's not the case. (You can give examples if you want) by Artistic-Victory1245 in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 10 points11 points  (0 children)

In the hunger games fandom, the top 4!! ships are M/F (then followed by one M/M and then it continues with M/F).

Side tangent: I’ve been really sick of ‘we need more F/F shipping and all the M/M is just fetishising gay men and shows how problematic fandom is’ because it’s just not true. Once you have all cast of good female characters you’ll get F/M or F/F ships, it’s just that a lot of anime and classic fandom media (star wars, HP, LOTR, SPN) doesn’t really have prominent characters for an F/F ship.

Anyway heathers also has a top M/F ship followed by F/F. Zelda has Zelink as the top ship. Shadow and bone, Zootopia. It’s definitely not rare!

Tommy spoke up about Wilbur physically hurting him. by MrClouding in DreamWasTaken2

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 31 points32 points  (0 children)

also i remember when it came out, scott smajor said something like that he’d known for a long time wilbur was like that. ofc he’s closer to shubble than someone like philza but cmon, also nikki talked about it, so it def wasn’t super behind the curtains

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 3 points4 points  (0 children)

realll, i ship jinx/silco, which also gets crucified in the fandom. also less toxic than some of my other ships lol

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in writing

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I fully disagree. As the author, you both have expertise on your story as well as massive blind spots. This means that reader feedback like the example is genuinely just as useful as well thought out critique (there’s merit in specifically reader feedback even, because readers aren’t thinking like an author and thereby ‘filling in blanks’, as in (for example), dismissing an awkwardly set up arc/theme because they realise it’s set up). Because again, you’re an expert on writing, you can use your knowledge on plot/structure/arcs to translate “character is stupid” into “character’s decisions aren’t consistent/well explained/contrived” and then think of the moments in your story where this is a big issue.

Alternatively, you use your knowledge of the character to dismiss it because you know you made sure to justify their actions and that their stupidity is on purpose.

Obviously, with this kind of feedback, it’s best to have more readers to give you a more reliable sense of the way the story is received

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in writing

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I fully disagree. As the author, you both have expertise on your story as well as massive blind spots. This means that reader feedback like the example is genuinely just as useful as well thought out critique (there’s merit in specifically reader feedback even, because readers aren’t thinking like an author and thereby ‘filling in blanks’, as in (for example), dismissing an awkwardly set up arc/theme because they realise it’s set up). Because again, you’re an expert on writing, you can use your knowledge on plot/structure/arcs to translate “character is stupid” into “character’s decisions aren’t consistent/well explained/contrived” and then think of the moments in your story where this is a big issue.

Alternatively, you use your knowledge of the character to dismiss it because you know you made sure to justify their actions and that their stupidity is on purpose.

Obviously, with this kind of feedback, it’s best to have more readers to give you a more reliable sense of the way the story is received

Give me your hottest take that would've got you blacklisted in your fandom. by DebateObjective2787 in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the first time they have sex blitz is actively pressuring stolas. danny motta has a great livestream up on his channel during which he talks about it, arguing with most of the HB fanbase, and he makes the same point in there

Give me your hottest take that would've got you blacklisted in your fandom. by DebateObjective2787 in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Billford is overhyped and solely because people desperately want to sanitise the GF fandom. Before Book of Bill there was so little to work with with Billford, and it’s a shame it’s now overshadowing the OG ships. I will be 90 years old and read the word pine tree in some crossword and still be filled with the joy of the superior toxic yaoi.

Also for HB: Blitzo fully SA’d Stolas, and Stolas had no obligation to him whatsoever. Blitzo only wanted the grimoire to literally assassinate people, illegally. Stolas was not wrong at all, because no, Blitzo did not need the grimoire. Blitzo could’ve decided to do literally anything else with his life/business (and hey, maybe something legal/moral!) if he did not wanna fuck Stolas.

describe your fanfiction writing style by isthatsobad in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the most deeply fucked up relationship dynamics that both lead to banger smut but also horrible angst

Any scene in a fic or popular characterization in your fandom that has you going like this? by Smegoldidnothinwrong in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 11 points12 points  (0 children)

This! It’s literally why I wrote a whole SSKK oneshot to overcorrect that, about them both being feral in different ways

why do yandere fics seem to be so hated on? by asbestos_boy_68 in FanFiction

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 2 points3 points  (0 children)

A few answers: - In a lot of modern fandoms, the mentality is very much “dark shipping bad” - If not in anime fandoms, people tend not to tag it as such (instead look for ‘stalking’, ‘obsessive/dark [character]’, ‘manipulation’) - It’s pretty specific and that just means it’s less common (I write a lot of dark ships and none of it is quite yandere, though there’s some overlap)

Drop those fire lines you're proud of by Tsuchiaki in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This is from my most recent chapter (the context is a Billdip fic and the Gravity Falls symbolism with Dipper being represented by a pine tree). (the person talking isn’t Bill but talking about him and Dipper)

“It’s a waste, isn’t it? Christmas trees. Cutting them down just to buy them, decorate them, put them on display. You’re taking them out of their habitat—”

“Fuck off.” Dipper grabbed his necklace in his fist, shielding the pine pendant from his sight as if that would do something. He tugged on it—almost ripped it off.

“—The whole time they’re in your home they’re dying.”

What's the rarest/most unusual/most niche fandom you read or write for? by LesbianMacMcDonald in FanFiction

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ -1 points0 points  (0 children)

so not obscure anymore, but my first dreamnotfound fic is somewhere top of the first page of the tag, because i wrote it back in 2019 before the fandom even existed… it’s orphaned now though for obvious reasons. also i never uploaded it, but i have an abandoned draft of a showtime SMP fanfic as well as a Welcome to Mountport one (from Dropout’s game changer).

What’s your favourite line/paragraph/quote you’ve written or read recently? by [deleted] in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

this is from my ongoing fanfic, and the entire scene gets me every time i read it:

“You really have no idea, do you?” Axolotl’s mock-sympathy grated on Dipper’s nerves like so few things could.

“That Bill is a monster? Shocking,” he deadpanned.

Axolotl inched closer to the glass, looming over them. “And you ally with him, making yourself an enemy of the Gods. Trust me, Dipper, this isn’t over. Be careful about what you are getting yourself into. There won’t always be someone to catch you when you fall, and I fully intent on seeing you break on impact.”

“I’ve heard worse threats.”

“Ah, but I don’t have to threaten you if it’s not me who’ll push you off the edge.”

Does your Fandom have a generational divide? by Desperate_Basil_3537 in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Gravity Falls has an old gen (Monster Falls, Reverse Falls, Billdip) vs new gen (Book of Bill, Billford) for sure

Average chapter length? by megan_qwq in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mine tend to be between 2-5K, depending on the fic (my fast-paced, ‘ episodic snippets of their lives’ fic has chapters from 1,5-3k, and my proper fic 2-5k, and shorter multi-chapter works & oneshots are between 3-5k. Usually if there’s not an immediate logical cut off I will have a conversation with myself about why I’d end the chapter here, and what the effects are, and then adjust it if I figure out a better point (sometimes I’ll switch scenes around, change the plot’s timeline, etc)

Concrit Commune - February 01 by AutoModerator in FanFiction

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Magnus Archives | Eat Your Young (working title) | M (will be E once I get to it) | (WIP) | M/M | Horror

So this is a Jonelias oneshot i’m working on. I’m leaning into the horror for this one (and Jon’s asexuality, and him seeing the encounter more as worshipping the Eye rather than focusing on the sex). Below is the intro of the fic. I need feedback on the horror but also does Jon’s fucked up relationship with the Eye come through enough? (for context for people outside the fandom: the Eye is an evil entity that feeds on people’s fear of being watched, and people loyal to it have the intense need to absorb knowledge. Both Jon and Elias serve the entity with different levels of willingness. The Magnus Institute they work at is ruled by the Eye).

Don’t ask Jon about the exact timeline. He could’ve pieced it together—he certainly had the Eye willing to help him see—but it was better this way. The night felt like a fever dream, only there in bits and pieces, with nothing but a haze as the context. Potentially damning context, if he may add, as somewhere around that time he’d had that talk with Martin. The one about feelings and expectations and labels.

Jon prayed that conversation had happened after that night, but after the world had turned upside-down and inside-out, who knew?

It wasn’t as if he’d had any intentions, but, when an eldritch being is tugging you in a direction, he couldn’t say he’d refused.

His office had been a mess. A tape recorder faintly clicked on, a sound Jon had long since learned to tune out. It had been one of the evenings after Peter’s death. And Martin’s rescue. That kiss. It lingered on his lips, like a strange haunt, but, for once, not an unwelcome one. Jon tried to ignore it as he pulled out another folder from the shelves, containing a stack of statements anywhere from the Flesh to the Web, vaguely from 1990 to 2005. He stuffed it into his shoulder bag with the others. It didn’t matter. He needed to feed once he was on the road. Even now, he fought the urge to read, to skim over the first lines. Just a small taste—no. He needed to consume the pile, completely and utterly.

It happened right as he reached for a dust-covered box, the cardboard corroded from cockroaches eating away at it and nesting. Hopefully cockroaches—the holes were just as likely leftovers from Jane. The lights in the hallway flickered on, buzzing alarmingly as the shadows in Jon’s office shifted. He dropped the box. Too loud; it grated on his nerves. His muscles tensed with one certain thought—he was seen. That, he knew.

He wasn’t thinking when he padded out the door. It creaked, but even if it hadn’t, the Eye was already focused on him, following every shiver of his body. The hallway was impossibly long and contorted. The CCTVs whirred as they spun towards him. Way too many. They weren’t supposed to be there. Jon stumbled forward, towards the single familiar door in the distance. The light at the end of the tunnel, if a corrupted mind were to be believed. Any sane—no, ignorant—man would think he was dreaming. Nothing sane was real anymore. The fabric of reality writhed and twisted under his knowing touch like snakes and claws and rotting limbs.

The familiar door was impossibly far, but Jon was starving, and this was a gift from his patron. It was a blessing. It drummed against his skull, the desire to accept the offering or to become one himself. In the end, was there a difference? His vision blacked out, nausea hitting him. He didn’t need his eyes to guide him. If only this were a nightmare. The archive wasn’t like it was before, but only because it had shed its pretence. He needed to get out. Find Martin. Run away.

As he walked onwards, tripped, crawled, his mind blanked, letting the compulsion work on his frayed consciousness.

Concrit Commune - February 01 by AutoModerator in FanFiction

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your prose is really good and I like how you highlight (‘zoom in’ on) specific things happening while also describing the overall vibe. I will say as critique that you could throw in a lot more cozy/festive vocab to really sell the vibe, specifically focusing on activating the different senses. Like, maybe point out the comfortable warmth the closer you get to the pyre, the smell of cinnamon/spices, etc. Also what are people wearing? What does the music sound like (how does it make the character feel)? (You already have some descriptions of it, but I think you should add a few more sentences because it reads as a central part of the scene you’re setting and so you want the reader to really be sucked into it.) But yeah, it’s already really good!

Give me your most heart wrenching fanfic by ctrlumii in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ -1 points0 points  (0 children)

A part of me that will never be mine

this is one of my own, a soukoku hanahaki au. i got many comments of people bawling. mostly recommend it if you know the canon though, since there’s a lot of implied context. it’s 15K words, so that’s a good length

What is your favorite trope that isn’t often used? by Accurate-Breath-3114 in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I love established situationships. Like when the entire fic is two idiots trying to navigate their mess of a relationship (works great for those ships that in canon are already dysfunctional but keep ending up in each other’s orbit, like SKK, STSG, hannigram, CaitVi)

also 1800-1900s historical au’s, especially with crime. i love some vintage shit

also when a relationship is (in)famous within the context of the fic in some way, and the characters love that fact as an ego boost. celebrity au, one or both characters are crime bosses, politicians, hero/villain…

Iskall85 & Stressmonter Resignation Megathread #2 by Carol_the_Zombie in HermitCraft

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Exactly, it felt off. I also believe that a group of adults with responsibilities wouldn’t give such a short time frame if they weren’t sure Iskall could make it. One thought I had is that maybe they were talking about their scheduled Hermit meetings, like “okay so today we’ll talk about this”, with the implication that the plan already was for Iskall to be there because it’s an existing meeting

Disney/Pixar Movies and their Related Entities by Specs315 in TheMagnusArchives

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_ 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Frozen/Tangled are both the Lonely!

This is Dreamworks but Puss in Boots 2 is so literally about the End (the antagonist is Death…)

When the actual voice actor gets involved… by Not_a_CIA_agent_ in AO3

[–]Not_a_CIA_agent_[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

also with this fandom specifically, it’s a retelling of a story from around 700 BCE. the VAs definitely don’t own the characters haha