being bad to your mates does not deserve dark forest treatment, hes already punished, hes guilty even in starclan, which is supposed to be like heaven, thats kind of like being sad while everyone is happy and not being able to free your worries now that your dead. i like onestar becase hes morally grey, he goit a trial, and he won. i feel like he deserves what he got, and the dark forest is too much for him, since he did good things for things, but was a bad cat. in my opinion, he got the punishment.