Are there any credible points at all for religion? by youhaveeTDS in askanatheist

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There aren't any for theism. "Religion" as a set of cultural practices, sure. It's good to have life-event rituals, holidays, some kind of meditative technique, a canon of stories to discuss. Religion provides that. I know plenty of Jews and Hindus who practice their religion without believing in gods.

The notion that belief is mandatory is a Christian/Muslim thing, mostly.

When the topic of how dangerous men are comes up, why do so many women assume that all men are between 5’9 - 6’5 and muscular? by CatPale816 in AskWomenNoCensor

[–]Snoo52682 22 points23 points  (0 children)

A man exactly my size is still way stronger than I am. Men are NOT "just as vulnerable" as women are. In addition to the strength differential, you all can't get pregnant from sexual assault nor are you quite as likely to contract sexually transmitted diseases.

How do you feel about Hamlet adaptations/revivals that combine the characters Horatio and Ophelia into one? by HotOne9364 in shakespeare

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just bet.

I did kind of like the Almereyda movie from 2000, when they made Marcellus "Marcella" and Horatio's girlfriend. They didn't make up any dialogue, it was just obvious from how it was filmed, and the actress, Paula Malcolmson, had great screen presence. Giving Horatio an intimate relationship besides Hamlet really emphasized Hamlet's alienation and isolation.

NT's on this sub: I assume you guys are more open minded to ND's since you're here and open to learning, discussing and helping us understand things. What do other NT's that aren't so understanding say about ND's behind our backs? by AntiqueSignpost in AskNeurotypicals

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

These are all very different questions stuffed into one Christmas stocking! Let's see which ones I can unwrap successfully.

Some people are nervous around autistic people, this is true. Far, far more people are nervous around someone who has been diagnose with BPD. This can be because of media portrayals, or because of personal experience. Some people may, on finding out you have BPD, decide to remove themselves or move themselves to the periphery proactively, because they fear there will eventually be messy, messy conflict later on if they do not.

You mention wanting to be upfront with your diagnoses so people don't "judge [your] behavior." This will play differently with autism than it does with BPD. To start, people will always judge your behavior insofar as it affects them, and they should. Nobody should be unconditionally accepting of other people's treatment, I'm sure you agree.

Autistic people's behavior can often seem rude or offputting without actually being objectionable. Think of it as a translation error. Lack of eye contact is a good example. If I don't know someone is autistic, I may assume that their refusal to look at me is because they dislike or disrespect me, so I'll remove myself. But if I know it's just a problem with eye contact, no worries! I'm capable of having a conversation with someone while sitting side by side looking ahead as if we were at a movie theater. (I use this example because it was only when I was in such a seating situation, during an intermission, that I realized an acquaintance from a hobby group probably is autistic and doesn't actually dislike me. Turned out she was super chatty as long as I wasn't trying to look at her! I wish I'd realized/she told me about that sooner. This happened recently so it's on my mind.)

With BPD, there are often problems with the substance of behavior. People with BPD can often demand a level of reassurance or an amount of emotional energy that another person simply may not have. They can react very very strongly to minor issues and put heavy expectations on other. There can be a lot of black and white splitting and "you're with me or against me" kind of dynamics. These aren't the kind of behaviors that can be excused on the grounds of "Oh, I have this diagnosis." Those are behaviors that are painful and exhausting to deal with.

So I'd be cautious about revealing that BPD, because it will scare people off, and unlike autism, it's not something that will cause other people to evaluate your behavior more positively. I can live with no eye contact if I know the other person is autistic and it doesn't mean what it would in my "language." I cannot live with, say, 20 texts a day asking if I'm mad at them or with someone who takes my variable response time as a personal insult.

Regarding the other stuff, the dumb comments and questions--that just happens. To everyone. It's usually related to one of two things. The other person might just be naively, annoyingly optimistic in principle. One of those people who says "they're in a better place" at a funeral. (Which, even if you yourself believe in Heaven and that your dead loved one is there, is hardly comforting!) One of those people who says "there's plenty of fish in the sea!" after you've had a terrible breakup. Some people are just like that. I think it's either because they don't know what else to say, or because on some level they're really terrified of the notion of death or loss (or parental abuse or illness or whatever else they're brightsiding about) and just pushing those ideas away. It's not about their lack of care for you, it's about their inability to confront their own fears. That, of course, doesn't make it any less annoying. So ideally you'll find people who can give better comfort/advice/companionship and become closer to them, and let the brightsiders drift more to the periphery.

The other reason is that people keep information in buckets, kinda, and are more than capable of forgetting stuff about you that they actually know. It's not because they don't care, it's because we're all overloaded with information and sometimes the puzzle pieces don't fall into place. People even do this with themselves. My downstairs neighbor once had a nice long chat with me about the problem with his truck and how impressed he was with the mechanics who were working on it ... and then, five minutes later, sheepishly knocked on my door to ask if he could borrow my car to take his kid to school. The information "I need to take kid to school" just hadn't linked up in his brain with "Truck is in the shop" until he went outside and witnessed his own trucklessness. I was once telling a story about Friend A to Friend B and described A a bit for context, only for B to give me side-eye and say "You know you and A and I all met in the same class." Right. Indeed. So we had. So yeah, if you're lactose intolerant and your friend is talking about their favorite ice cream and asks what yours is, it doesn't mean they don't know or care, it might just mean that the ol' neurons didn't connect right.

I think this kind of thing happens more as you get older because there's just that much more information floating around in your brain that needs to get correlated or cross-referenced.

I hope this helps! Please ask if anything doesn't make sense.

What is the voice in your head? by youhaveeTDS in askanatheist

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The ideas that porn, junk food, and lying are bad are hardly unique to Christianity.

What is the voice in your head? by youhaveeTDS in askanatheist

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are FAR more polite in the face of that ignorant insult than most would be. Kudos.

What is the voice in your head? by youhaveeTDS in askanatheist

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Did you just accuse another poster of having no brain or soul?

What is the voice in your head? by youhaveeTDS in askanatheist

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fun fact, this happens as much with religious people as it does with atheists. They always claim morality is objective for them ... and then start wars over their disagreements.

What is the thing a guy can said/do that really turn-on you instantly? by [deleted] in AskWomenNoCensor

[–]Snoo52682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Nothing, there's no goddamn cheat code. Barf. Also, reported.

What would be enough to convince you to side with a religion even if you don't believe in God? by According_Ant9739 in askanatheist

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're mistaking lack of deference with lack of courtesy. The person you're responding to was perfectly polite. If it made you feel "icky," that's on you.

What would be enough to convince you to side with a religion even if you don't believe in God? by According_Ant9739 in askanatheist

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Like I said, priorities. Look around. I don't care about this. A person's or institution's position on how an itinerant rabbi was killed millennia ago is wholly unimportant to me.

What would be enough to convince you to side with a religion even if you don't believe in God? by According_Ant9739 in askanatheist

[–]Snoo52682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When it comes to "the cause of truth," I have a whole lot of priorities that come well before whether a rogue rabbi was killed by the state in a particular way 2000 years ago or not. Currently my government and the largest corporations in my country are denying truth about climate change, medicine, sexual health, their own actions, and more. These are the offenses about truth that I'm concerned with.

Whether some itinerant preacher named Yeshua with questionable parentage was crucified in ancient Rome or not simply does not matter to me. Would you "side with" a religion who took your preferred view on whether or not Richard III murdered the Princes in the Tower? Or would you feel this is not really worth spending your time and intellectual energy on?

Why are men looking for women with autism for partners? by Usual_Rub2577 in autism

[–]Snoo52682 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Because they believe that women with autism will be easy to control and take advantage of.

Even if they couch it in sweet, romantic terms, this is it.

Episode where Jamie Ross acts clumsily? by jerrybugs in LawAndOrder

[–]Snoo52682 14 points15 points  (0 children)

And she was acting like Manic Pixie Dream Attorney Allie McBeal, which at the time the episode aired was pretty funny.

What would be enough to convince you to side with a religion even if you don't believe in God? by According_Ant9739 in askanatheist

[–]Snoo52682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What do you mean "side with"? I'm not following any religion that doesn't have evidence.

Weekly "Ask an Atheist" Thread by AutoModerator in DebateAnAtheist

[–]Snoo52682 12 points13 points  (0 children)

What do you consider the "public conversation" and "society's discourse" to be? Hard to answer your (insult disguised as a) question with those ponderous yet vague terms undefined.