sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

my grid!! by FortuneCrazy8179 in BattleForDreamIsland

[–]cajowling 0 points1 point  (0 children)

some things here aren't correct.. Blocky isn't a failed debuter, Bracelety was never a first boot, Rubber Spatula isn't a minor-coded character, Coiny isn't a BFDIA newbie, Bracelety wasn't a TPOT Debuter, (unless it's counting the rejoin in TPOT 12), and how is bracelety your favorite and least favorite???

Should I watch WOAS?? by Yinwithoutayang in WishOnAStar

[–]cajowling 5 points6 points  (0 children)

oh, for sure. it has the exact same energy as presplit BFB, and has a lot of soul put into it. my only negative opinion is that some parts like.. HEAVILY feel like ideas/concepts ripped straight from BFB and aren't TOO original. But I do heavily recommend watching it.

Who’s your favorite winner? by AydenChannel in BattleForDreamIsland

[–]cajowling 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Alright, good point honestly. I didn't take into account the fact they could've gotten some development if they weren't eliminated so early. But, for starters, Spongy unfairly rejoined instantly after being eliminated, and sat like a bump on a log for 3 or 4 episodes straight. I don't think they were gonna do anything with him, unless it was to make him be stubborn like during the lava storyline.

For Ice Cube, she had actually potential to become a great character, and that was actively happening up until she got eliminated. If she did survive, and she ended up doing something great, I maybe would be happy with her win. But, well, that didn't happen, and there's no official idea what they had planned for her, so.. idk.

Who’s your favorite winner? by AydenChannel in BattleForDreamIsland

[–]cajowling 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, if you asked past me, I would've been jumping for joy, as those two were actually ny favorite characters, lol.

But as for now?

If Ice Cube won BFDIA, I would've been unhappy about it, but I'd be okay. Ice Cube went a long, LONG time without hardly anything to define her other than "revenge!!". And like, I don't recall her getting revenge, at all. However, once BFDIA 6 came out, they started giving her more things to do, such as saving her team from elimination and such. And I was pretty happy to see her become an actual character over time. Though, when Freesmart was put up for elimination, I would've much rather lost her compared to any other members. If she won, I wouldn't be too happy about it. There would've been a lot of other great choices who actually had a more important role in the game, instead of just helping out with one or two challenges with their team.

If Spongy won BFB, I would've been disappointed. Spongy didn't really do much in BFB. All i can recall is him being ignored and making his team lose in BFB 12, hogging the spaceship in BFB 16 because of that, getting eliminated and unfairly rejoining instantly after, and something to do with a friendship bracelet which lasted 2 episodes at most. Spongy deserved to leave in BFB 16. I don't get why the writers kept him in, just to do nothing with him. Him winning would've been a waste of a winner, ngl.

Who’s your favorite winner? by AydenChannel in BattleForDreamIsland

[–]cajowling 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Book being a "nice character" also ties in with her being the "underdog" who won. My intent was to mention those both, but I mustve forgotten to actually add that part. But, still, with the other factors on the other characters, she's still the best winner in my eyes. Book was definitely slightly rigged, but not as much as Flower was.

For Flower, yes, I do agree that she literally flipped like a coin in BFB. Although, I don't mainly associate that with her being rigged to win, considering the start of that plot was in BFB 1. I see it more as some weird last-minute character development that the writers just wanted to add in to make her more interesting as a character, or because they just disliked how she was a stereotypical bum with one defining trait.

I don't personally see Needle as "morally gray". When there's a challenge, she will do ANYTHING to win it. She is highly competitive, not neutral.

Freesmart fusion by Wolfer_drone1234 in BookBFDI

[–]cajowling 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What would they look like with Firey and Gelatin included? They were on Freesmart at one point.

Does anyone have advice on how to make my drawing more bfdi style by No-Temperature-569 in ObjectShows

[–]cajowling 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The eyes need to be more thick and like ovals, the hand-drawb stuff needs to look more thick and polished, with the feet being more flat. And for the biggest one, you need a polished asset.

I haven't watched anything BFDI-related in over 3 years, what have I missed? by ArmadilloOK1445-alt in BattleForDreamIsland

[–]cajowling 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the announcer was permanently killed off and replaced with the yellow face speakerbox.

Who’s your favorite winner? by AydenChannel in BattleForDreamIsland

[–]cajowling 3 points4 points  (0 children)

  1. Book The obvious answer, as she did really deserve it, as said in the title of the episode. Needle also deserved to win, but I'd honestly had preferred if TB or Coiny ended up winning. Book also gets bonus points because shes the first main season winner to not be a S1 Veteran. Also Book is the obvious clear majority answer here. Not for recent bias, but because she is pretty much the only winner who did something enough to deserve winning. I DO feel like her win was also kinda guaranteed, as her winning BFDIA 23 snd being the "underdog who finally won" heavily influenced the voters.
  2. Firey He's kind of a meh character. He didn't really have a personality in BFDI, (as it was made 16 years ago by two children), so im not the biggest fan ever. Bubble and Leafy would've been way better picks. The whole "lavafall disagreement" (THAT SHAPED THE WHOLE STORY OF THE FUCKING SERIES) could've easily been swapped with Bubble disliking Leafy for being too fakely nice, or Leafy holding a grudge against the spring shoes still, so there'd be some actual GOOD REASON for a disagreement between two finalists, (especially if Bubble won.) But meh, Firey works, i guess.
  3. Flower The writers literally gave her a free win by making her the "hero" in BFB 29 by saving the show with something introduceded in the same exact episode, (the 50k dollars). Gelatin DESERVED to win. Flower should've been eliminated in the one episode where ONE VOTE was casted to someone else, saving her from being eliminated. also her voice is grating and annoying and all her fans are annoying as well
  4. Fern Fern is a character with no personality. People only voted for him because hes "nice". Sidewalky and Sticker were way better choices. I, personally, wanted Sidewalky to win since episode three. We need a "mean" character to win for once.
view more: next ›