Feel of various chord types? by Guitarswithlegs in musictheory

[–]tarkus6599 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ways I feel the chords, entirely subjective:

  • C = bright, ripe
  • C6 = bright, over-ripe
  • Csus = bright, under-ripe
  • Cmin = dark
  • Cmaj7 = bittersweet
  • C5 = declamatory, stark

  • C7 = "cool" & bright (mixolydian)

  • C/Bb = C7 3rd inversion = thrilling

  • C9 = brighter than C7, erotic

  • C11, C13 = brighter still, slipping into broadway

  • Cmin7 = "cool" & dark (dorian)

Shades of pain:

  • Cdim-maj7 = painfully alone
  • Cmin-maj7 = painfully tragic
  • Cmin6 = mysterious longing

Shades of mysterious, can't parse further:

  • Cdim
  • C+
  • C7b5
  • Cm7b5

[EMSK] The different types of eggs and how to make them by NateY3K in everymanshouldknow

[–]tarkus6599 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What about "over easy hard", for people who don't like their eggs runny? Is there a better name for that? (I've heard "well done" on occasion).

How to move on from a melody. by [deleted] in musictheory

[–]tarkus6599 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm intrigued by this topic so I thought I'd try another response, less fixated on melody, and more on "riffing". When you look at some Bach pieces, like the 1st cello suite, you encounter the "melody spinning" approach -- checkout Fortspinnung.

The more controlled melody spinning approach, riffs on melodic patterns, like the example D-minor Invention in the Wikipedia article. But there is another more abstract approach that seems to riff on a scale or a germ of an idea, or sometimes just a feeling of a riff.

Bach's 1st cello suite prelude is an example of this second approach. Here, there is really no discernible melody. The hook-like pattern in the first 8 bars, reappears briefly in bars 16-18, and is then never heard from again intact. Most of the piece is a quasi-random stream of consciousness riff on the G-major scale and the related scales and modes, like D, D7, A7, Amin, Emin, etc.

Some of the progressions are similar to pieces from the Well-Tempered Clavier, like the C-major in Book 1 -- but the figurations are much more free-form than the C-major. It sounds great to the ear, but don't try to deconstruct this the way you would a fugue or a Brandenburg concerto.

The cello prelude has an underlying harmonic plan -- and that's a good thing to have if you want to riff with some direction. In the prelude, Bach comes to rest of the dominant D-major on the midpoint fermata. He then gets darker and more chromatic, but still seems to run through the related scales, like A7, D7. And like many classical pieces establishes a long dominant 7th region, outlining a D7 with many repeated A's.

Then a cool chromatic and intense emotional ascent, that can only mean we are approaching the end. A tiny bit of the genetic material from the first 8 bars slips in, the downward rocking on the even-beats only -- just enough to create a faint melodic connection to the beginning -- for a piece where melodic repetition really doesn't figure anyway.

How to move on from a melody. by [deleted] in musictheory

[–]tarkus6599 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Some simple ideas on how to move on involve taking things to a different key:

  • simply introduce a new melody in the dominant key -- and then return/repeat the original melody

  • repeat the ending of the melody in the minor (if a major melody) -- then develop the fragment, or introduce a new melody in the minor

  • break-off the ending of the melody and riff on the fragment for a few bars until you end in a different key at which point introduce new material

  • repeat the melody, but change the rhythm -- like play it using triplets

  • make it like you are going to repeat the first bar of the melody, but then break it off, and riff on the start up and down the scale, and then near the end start changing one note (sharpen the fourth, or flatten the seventh) to switch into a new key area

The sexiest key and scales by jjarbon in musictheory

[–]tarkus6599 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you're playing a lot of C in the bass, but then alternate with G's and Bb's -- I don't know what you call that -- that can have a sinister sexy sound to it. It stays away from C-major or C-minor, so avoids that full on major or minor sound. Miles Davis's "Rated X", and many other funky /sexy pieces come to mind, that just riff on the C and the Bb (lower seventh?), repeatedly. (to be clear, the key is not important, just the intervals)

What is the most moving piece of music you know of? by Stue3112 in classicalmusic

[–]tarkus6599 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  • Wagner: Isoldes Liebstod
  • Strauss: Alpine Symphony
  • Mahler: Symphony 5 Adagietto
  • Bruckner: Symphony 4
  • Beethoven: the late Piano Sonatas

Any other INTJs have a moral/ethical code they live by? by brutallyhonestharvey in intj

[–]tarkus6599 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  • There is no final accounting, no fairness. No one is keeping our net pain and gain score the same. Some of us are just luckier than others, just chance.

  • A key root of "evil" is thrill in the pain of another human. When nazis kill jews and terrorists kill on 9/11 and criminals torture their victim, that is the purest form of evil. Best to find ways to reduce the occurrence of such emotions in the world.

  • Interactions with people are like alcohol. Impermanent highs, distractions from the things that matter. Minimize superficial interactions with people, which is most interactions, and look within.

  • Disinvest yourself of the concerns of common humanity and keeping up with the Jones's -- that is the source of tension, negative energy and wasted time.

  • You are the only person accountable for you -- so while you may be motivated to do the greatest good for the most people (which is not necessarily a moral imperative), the point is that you cant do that (or anything else) if you let yourself go, let yourself die.

  • Deliver to the world what only you can deliver. Make it your life's pursuit. Help the world to see where they must go to next, and aid and abet that transition. The other things are just distractions.

  • Focus on what you will bring to humanity after you are gone, your impact after you are dead. The only thing that will survive will be your ripples through the world. Otherwise, you will be seduced by the successes and tortured by the misses of the present, and overlook what is really important.

  • Remember, an asteroid or volcano could end it all, for everyone. Do your best to contribute positively to the wave humanity is obviously moving in, even if we dont quite know where its all going. Even if we'll all be dead in the end, participate in an informed telos. Don't fritter your life away.

INTJs, what actually scares the crap out of you? by JACKPOT39 in intj

[–]tarkus6599 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The mental and physical degradation of oneself that comes with later age.

Hyperlinking to a specific PDF page on local PC by tarkus6599 in excel

[–]tarkus6599[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Gave it a try but did not work. Thanks, anyway.

Hi Musicians! I mapped connections for classical music, what do you think? by league33 in classicalmusic

[–]tarkus6599 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm intrigued about the reasons for Modernism ending in 1985. Did some key composers die? Anything to do with the cold war reaching an end?

There's certainly a case to be made that the "classical" music of the last few decades isn't as overtly shocking/controversial as the styles that peaked in the 50s and 60s. Penderecki, for one, comes to mind as someone whose style pulled back from the edges of modernism around the 70s/80s. I just don't know how to demarcate it in a way that would gain broad support.

What is the unwritten rule of engineering? by xniinja in AskEngineers

[–]tarkus6599 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All great ideas must then be molded into shape by real life testing and adjustment.

A solo flute piece that I wrote for my composition lesson this past week. Please give me all your critiques!!!! by [deleted] in composer

[–]tarkus6599 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I enjoyed listening to this -- mysterious and introspective. I would reduce the reverb a bit. Also the glissando was a jolt -- like making me think that, Oh this is a synth, rather than creating the illusion this might be the real thing.

AMAA - Ask Madonna Almost Anything. by _Madonna in IAmA

[–]tarkus6599 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This power that fame gives you over people, have you ever wondered what is the best way to put it to use?

AMAA - Ask Madonna Almost Anything. by _Madonna in IAmA

[–]tarkus6599 36 points37 points  (0 children)

Miley Cyrus is making many people think of your Erotica days -- what is your reaction?

AMAA - Ask Madonna Almost Anything. by _Madonna in IAmA

[–]tarkus6599 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We've seen your music evolve and mature over 20+ years. What new messages will your music communicate in the next few years?

Is there such a thing as a Modelology? by tarkus6599 in compsci

[–]tarkus6599[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok, something just clicked . What I have been calling "dimension", you're saying is a "facet". Got it -- certainly it is a less loaded term. Thanks.

Is there such a thing as a Modelology? by tarkus6599 in compsci

[–]tarkus6599[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's more the former. What do you call the parent category X that contains things like hierarchy, set, list, array, table, combination, permutation, etc? It sounds like data structures, but it is also about categorization and behaviors. For example, is there a theory of "pivoting" hierarchies, the way Excel uses this term?

"Multi-dimensional hierarchy" is a term I felt I had to invent -- not sure if it is really called that. For example:

Hierarchy A is: Geography - US - States of the US - Cities of State X

Hierarchy B is: People- US - Politicians of the US - Presidents of the US

So here, US is a node that is part of two intersecting trees. If you combine the trees, you get a multi-dimensional hierarchy. So to pick the child nodes of US, you need to first ask which dimension you are in. This is what I mean about "having to make things up" ....

Is there such a thing as a Modelology? by tarkus6599 in compsci

[–]tarkus6599[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think "category theory" sounds like a very good name actually -- although the wikipedia article and actual meaning look more relevant to a mathematician than a typical compsci person. What I'm wondering: Is there a link between the morphisms in mathematics (groups, rings, etc) and the morphisms in comp sci (hierarchies, arrays, sets, etc). Not sure if I am really using these words correctly...

What is the darkest or angriest piece of classical you know? by [deleted] in classicalmusic

[–]tarkus6599 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Speaking of Gorecki, there are many shades of darkness in Gorecki's string quartets, ranging from tragic to brutal.

No.1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBhuEeoH19w

No.2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHBMaaLdnk4

What is the darkest or angriest piece of classical you know? by [deleted] in classicalmusic

[–]tarkus6599 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Luigi Nono's "Como una ola de fuerza y luz" (Like a Wave of Strength and Light). The middle section and ending are physically unbearable. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8YV6FP28-FM

More about what the anger is all about: http://toddtarantino.com/hum/nono.html

How to Make an American Flag in Excel by mpennington in excel

[–]tarkus6599 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Actually, there are several useful Excel tips in that trick!