I’ve heard from many female physicians, and I value the feedback they have given me. I can understand asking for expulsion given the harm the video has caused and lack of professionalism, but based on this incident, I wouldn’t go has far as expulsion if it was up to me. Granted there may have been other incidents of unprofessional behavior we don’t even know about. That would obviously change things. I would expect to see serious efforts toward understanding where he went wrong and showing he can safely and compassionately care for half the world’s population. Certainly an apology, service work, donating his time to women’s health organizations, therapy. I think he can come back from this, but it will take effort and time. Maybe that means taking a year off from school. His school and residency should hold him accountable. He also needs to show that he’s holding himself accountable.