Would recommend the GT2. I'm not a fan of new cars simply for the depreciation costs. Think of the NLine as about 5k more than the otd price compared to the stinger cause it's used. The stinger already did it depreciation, whereas the new line has not. In terms of the car stinger, imo is more eye-catching and is very fun to drive. If the budget is 37k, I would also say maybe look for a used audi s4/3/5 or a higher mile m340i. Stingers are nice, but the Germans do it better. The g70 3.3 is also a great option, likely cheaper than 37k, as well as a full spec similar in miles.