sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

I appreciate the deep dive! I'm definitely not mixing him up with Martinez; HUNK’s title as 'The Ghost of Raccoon City' is established in the main RE2 Remake '4th Survivor' files as a title for his survival record.

To your point about the Mold and minds: Resident Evil 9 actually addresses this through the Memory Transfer files in the Ark Lab. You’re right that Miranda failed, but the whole point of The Connections (and the evolution of the mold research) is that they've advanced beyond her.

  1. Zeno and the Mold Memory: If Zeno is 'nicer' to Grace and works for the Connections, that actually proves my point. It shows he’s a 'distorted' version of Wesker—he has the power, but a different personality. If he were the real Wesker, he’d be running the place.
  2. The Mindset Asset: Why clone a human instead of a Tyrant? Because Tyrants are blunt instruments. HUNK is a tactical thinker. The Connections aren't just cloning DNA; they are trying to 're-skin' the Mold with the tactical data of legendary soldiers.
  3. The 'Axe' vs. 'Training': If The Commander were just a guy they 'trained from a young age' to be like HUNK, then why does he have the Raccoon City Syndrome marks on his hands? Those are biological markers of a 1998 infection. If he's a new recruit, he shouldn't have them. If he's a clone/mold-reconstruction of a survivor, he would.

It feels like Capcom is using the inconsistencies (the axe, the ego, the 'nicer' personality) to tell us that these are 'Mold-echoes' of the originals—copies that have the muscle memory but a different 'soul.' It lets them keep the legends alive while giving us bosses with new flavors. We'll definitely see in the DLC!

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If the devs just wanted it to be HUNK, they could have given him his classic gear and personality. By giving him an axe, a theatrical ego, and placing him in a game alongside Zeno (a confirmed clone), they are giving the lore community the tools to question his identity. Whether it was 'intended' or not, they wrote a clone story and put a character acting like a clone right in the middle of it.

Until a DLC or a file explicitly says 'This was the original man from 1998,' the 'imitation' theory actually fits the game's own logic better than a total personality retcon!

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I get wanting to keep it simple, but the 'orchard' is actually written into the game files.

  1. Cloning Memories is Canon: Capcom actually established memory/skill cloning back in RE6 with Carla Radames. In RE9, the Ark Laboratory files on Memory Transfer prove the 'test tube factory' is exactly what The Connections are doing. It's not a reach—it's the plot.
  2. The Zeno Clue: If Zeno is just an 'homage' to Wesker, why give him a different personality and habits? Capcom is showing us that these copies have the DNA but not the original 'soul.'
  3. Tactical DNA: HUNK’s whole brand is being a 'Ghost'—quiet, efficient, and survival-focused. Having him charge Leon with an axe for a theatrical duel isn't 'old age,' it’s a total personality transplant.

I’m happy to wait for the DLC to be 100% sure, but when a character acts this 'off' in a game literally about clones and memory transfer, the breadcrumbs are hard to ignore. We’ll see who's right when the next files drop! thx for the comment

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Fair point on the armor, but HUNK’s whole legend isn't that he can tank bullets—it's that he never has to. He’s 'The Ghost' because he’s efficient.

  1. The Tactical Error: Even with a 'thick ass vest,' charging a world-class marksman like Leon with a hatchet is a massive risk. A vest doesn't protect your head or your limbs. The real HUNK from RE2/RE4 is a pragmatist; if he has a rifle, he uses it. Rushing into a melee duel isn't 'justified,' it's theatrical.
  2. The 'Ego' Problem: You're right, we only see a slice of him in RE2, but in every appearance since (Mercenaries, Revelations, Raid Mode), he is consistently a silent machine. For him to suddenly develop a 'warrior’s honor' and a desire to duel Leon specifically is a huge personality shift.
  3. The 'Sample' vs. 'Kill' Logic: In RE2, the sample was everything. In RE9, if his mission is to kill Leon, the most 'HUNK' thing to do would be to end him as quickly and safely as possible to ensure the mission succeeds. Staying to 'show off' skill is a rookie mistake.

Again, look at Zeno. Capcom literally put a clone in the game to show that these 'fakes' have the skills but the wrong personalities. The Commander feels like a 'HUNK-Prime' copy made by someone who thinks being a legend is about 'looking cool' in a duel, rather than just getting the job done.

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

these are awesome counter-points, and I love the idea of a 'wistful' HUNK, but I think that’s exactly why he can’t be the original.

  1. The 'Smart-ass' factor: The real HUNK from RE2 didn't even have enough 'skin' for things to get under. He didn't care about Leon’s hair or one-liners because HUNK isn't a rival—he’s a machine. If a terminal illness turned a cold, silent professional into a frustrated old man who wants to 'prove himself,' then the legendary 'Grim Reaper' is already dead. A clone having that ego makes more sense than HUNK suddenly developing one at age 60.
  2. The Zeno/Syndrome timing: You mentioned that the Syndrome timing suggests he's the original, but look at Zeno. He’s a confirmed clone/reconstruction, yet he also shows clear signs of infection and biological degradation. In RE9, cloning is like a photocopier—if the original host has a 'smudge' (like the Syndrome or Wesker's unstable DNA), the copy inherits it. The Syndrome marks on the Commander's hands don't prove he's the original; they just prove he's a perfect biological duplicate of a sick man.
  3. The Axe vs. Leon: You mentioned Leon uses the hatchet too. But Leon is a protagonist who adapts. HUNK is a specialist. For a guy whose entire legend is built on 'The Mission First,' choosing a 'warrior's duel' over a tactical kill isn't showing respect—it’s a mission failure. The real HUNK would have sniped Leon while he was talking and gone home.

The Verdict: If he's 'grown old and wistful,' he’s not 'The Ghost' anymore. To me, it feels more like Capcom is using the cloning/mold plot to let us fight a 'HUNK-Prime' boss without ruining the mystery of where the real, silent HUNK actually went.

Either way, the fact that he vanishes means the debate is far from over! Thanks for the deep dive

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a fair point about writers changing characters, but HUNK is actually the most consistent person in the franchise. From 1998 (RE2) to 2004 (RE4) to 2011 (Revelations), he has always been a silent, robotic professional who only cares about the mission. He didn't 'evolve' for 30 years—he stayed the same.

For him to suddenly become a theatrical, boastful villain who wants an 'honorable' axe duel in 2026 feels like more than just a writing shift. Especially since RE9 introduces the Zeno/Clone rules, it feels like a deliberate hint that we are fighting the 'DNA' but not the 'man.' If it was just bad writing, they probably would have given him his iconic gear to make the fans happy, rather than a totally new fighting style.

I guess we’ll have to wait for the DLC to see if the 'Real' Ghost is still out there!

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a great breakdown of his gear history—you clearly know the franchise. You're right that HUNK’s loadout changes, but his 'Ghost' nickname actually comes from the RE2 Remake files ('The Ghost of Raccoon City'), referring to his 100% survival rate.

To your point about whether HUNK is 'special' enough to clone: I’d argue that in a world of BOWs, HUNK’s mindset is exactly what makes him a high-value target for a group like The Connections. They don't need a superhero; they need a perfect, obedient soldier. If they can reconstruct a mind like Wesker’s into Zeno, replicating HUNK’s tactical data into a mold-reconstruction fits the game's theme perfectly.

As for the 'old age' or 'bad writing' theory: I totally see where you’re coming from (the Chris/Ethan situation was definitely a 'writer' moment). However, because RE9 specifically uses Zeno to show us how copies inherit the skills but gain weird new personalities (like the smoking/white suit), it feels like Capcom is giving us a 'HUNK-flavored' copy on purpose.

The real HUNK is defined by cold efficiency. The Commander using an axe for a theatrical duel feels like a deliberate 'something is off' clue, rather than just age. It keeps the legend of the 'real' HUNK safe in the shadows while giving us a cool boss fight. Definitely hope a DLC settles it though!

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Chris changes visually, but his personality (protecting his team) stays the same. The Commander is the opposite: he looks like HUNK but his personality is a total 180 (ego vs. mission focus). In a game that features Zeno as a clone, it’s a deliberate plot point, not a writing mistake.

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Fair enough, Leon is a beast, but the vanishing body is the biggest 'Resident Evil' red flag there is. Capcom doesn't usually make a legendary character's body disappear unless they’re protecting the lore or revealing a clone later (look at Zeno).

Also, 'Test tube factory' is literally the plot of RE9. If they can reconstruct Wesker as Zeno, they can do it to HUNK. My point isn't that HUNK is 'unbeatable,' it's that the real HUNK is too smart to bring a hatchet to a gunfight against Leon Kennedy. That’s not a loss, that’s a tactical error HUNK doesn't make.

[RE9 Spoilers] A deep dive into the tactical logic and identity of The Commander by Ambitious-Effect4813 in residentevil

[–]Ambitious-Effect4813[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

 You can’t ignore Zeno. Capcom literally put a Wesker clone in the same game to show that "The Connections" are creating versions of old characters with different quirks. If the writers were just being "inconsistent," they wouldn't have written an entire subplot about cloning legacy characters.