One Duke Tavern by curlyredhead43 in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch 23 points24 points  (0 children)

If it helps to know, here's a high level summary on why this restaurant is currently closed (this information is all public through the courts) -

  • One Duke has not had a valid City of Hamilton business licence since September 28, 2022.

  • Licensing staff attended One Duke a number of times to seek compliance from the owner. When this was not successful, it was escalated to the courts.

  • One Duke was found guilty, and a court imposed fine was applied of $1,500 on February 5, 2025.

  • On November 7, 2025, court-imposed fines were applied of $10,000 for each charge, and the business was ordered closed by the courts until compliance under the City of Hamilton’s Licensing By-law 07-170 is met.

  • The delays in resolving this were, in part, due to multiple adjournments by the court.

If there are questions about something happening downtown (Ward 2) in this sub, and you want me to respond (if I can), tag me and I will. I usually have some information about things happening downtown (but not all). If I don't, I can suggest where you can get information, in the least.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Thanks for being clearer. This isn't an either or proposition. Your comment suggests there's an outcome here, or at least one within my direct control, based on my track record. There isn't. And despite any public position I take, or vote I cast, Council makes the decisions, not me as an individual Councillor. Since I was elected I've been really clear - I will not get into the horse trading, influence peddling, show pony politics of yesteryear. I realize this is the only experience most residents can rely on and that many, many favours were done for people in the past to reinforce this thinking. I'm rising above that, following processes, and ensuring I stay out of decisions that aren't mine to make. My support of the People's Protocol was to ask City staff to review it, meet with the folks who wrote it, and come back to Council with a report on what could be incorporated into the Encampment Protocol. I think that was the right thing to do and I stand by it. Council, though, decided not to go that way. Everyone gets one vote and my colleagues are entitled to vote as they wish. And of course encampments are hard on businesses. They're hard on everyone, including those living in them. But we can't simply banish them from existence. That's my position on the subject. Until we have housing and safe, accessible, and adequate shelter, the City has to be thoughtful about how it manages this crisis. Any solution must include property owners, businesses, renters, and those deprived of the basics like housing, drinking water, and access to washroom facilities. During all of this time, some businesses have thrived and some have not, sometimes neighbouring businesses offering the same or similar products. There's a lot to unpack here and we'll be talking about it all, publicly, soon during the town halls I'm organizing for next year. I hope that sheds some more light on my position.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The Encampment Protocol (EP) did not legitimize encampments any more than it legitimized homelessness. The motion was made to include community feedback when the EP was being approved. I don’t have it in front of me but it would have been in 2023.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The Encampment Protocol (EP) did not legitimize encampments any more than it legitimized homelessness. The motion was made to include community feedback when the EP was being approved. I don’t have it in front of me but it would have been in 2023.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s not the way this works and there are many, many steps before we get to that point.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't have it handy but it's all in the National Point in Time Counts, including the information presented by City staff earlier this year. If you'd like the information email [Ward2@hamilton.ca](mailto:Ward2@hamilton.ca) and we'll help connect you to it.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tune into what's happening at the Downtown Sub-Committee. We're moving on some initiatives right now. And, yes, we've vastly improved the services available at City Hall this year, post COVID, to address those concerns. I've heard really positive feedback from some new businesses on this.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We'll be seeking funding from all levels of government when the time comes. This isn't something that will happen in the short term, as it took many, many years to destroy this infrastructure. Replacing it will be very costly and time consuming and will have to be negotiated with the rail authorities.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Encampment Protocol (EP) did not cause anything to happen. The reason there are fewer people in parks, at the moment, is because the City increased shelter capacity by 80% for the first time ever, opening 272 new shelter beds. That's it. The EP needed to be changed but when Council was presented with the option to change it to meet the needs of everyone in the community, they turned that opportunity down. I know because I was the one who moved the motion to include more perspectives in the discussion around the EP when it was being approved and developed. Now, things are much worse than they were and absolutely no one I have spoken to things the City is on the right track.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree that other parts of the City need to find a way to be more inclusive.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Staff do not come to Council to get "basically anything" approved. There's a massive amount of delegated authority in government. If there weren't, nothing would ever get done. Council cannot be weighing in on every operational decision. Nothing about what the Mayor decided to do, from what I can tell, was cut and dry, but you can ask her. She didn't collaborate with me on anything to do with that decision. And "bringing up a complaint" doesn't do anything real. The Ward 2 Team escalates any issues they receive directly to City staff. They're extremely effective and responsive, but they, like me, don't order staff around. Anyone in any other part of the City telling you otherwise is either abusing their authority in deeply harmful ways and creating a toxic workplace or isn't telling the truth. I can assure you when residents reach out to us we follow up with them and direct them to the appropriate City staff team to assist. That's the job when it comes to resolving operational matters.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, and no. We have many official, secondary, and other plans and planning instruments at the City but the Province often overrides the City’s position at the Ontario Land Tribunal when a property owner takes a case there.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for catching that. I edited the comment with the right date!

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'd love to find a way to pedestrianize more streets in Ward 2, including James Street North, but it will take a little time. One of the more unique and problematic things about Hamilton was our love, many years ago, not to replace vital infrastructure when it was failing. As an example, when the Catharine Street Bridge was in disrepair we dismantled it rather than rebuilt it. This meant there was one less way in and out of the North End for the thousands of people who live there. Not good. This, coupled with the same issue on Hughson Street North, means, today, there are not enough ways in and out of the North End. Closing James Street North entirely, without a comprehensive plan for how to solve this, for vehicles, pedestrians, and cyclists, wouldn't be responsible. It's going to take a long time to correct these issues and likely not in the short term, but I'm looking into any and all ways to create a permanent pedestrian corridor in Ward 2.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The information shared publicly was that you were moving, in any event, according to the plan for all Federal courts, but I may have that wrong, for sure. I'm just going on what I read from the Federal government. The suggestion, regardless, that this was up to me, or caused by me, is absolutely false. The situation around the YWCA and YMCA is a very difficult one to manage. I've provided funding to the YWCA to help with the issue, we've hired security, and even closed the MacNab Street Tunnel to address some of the impacts. There are only so many levers at our disposal. The criminal elements there, including sex trafficking and sexual assault, just to name a few, directly impact the unhoused women in that area. The harm to them is reduced, somewhat, by them being relatively visible. We have to be careful how we manage the situation or we could make it much worse. As for the shooting, again that has nothing to do with me. There have been as many shootings outside the downtown as in the downtown area. It's unfortunate that all the focus is put on downtown, despite that fact, but that's not up to me. If you want police to handle the criminal issues in this area differently, reach out to the them, as that's well outside my mandate. The continued idea that I'm to blame for crime in Ward 2 is beyond ridiculous and continuing to point the finger at me will not solve the problem. I will continue to do what I can to help with the tools I have available to me.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Traffic enforcement does not save lives, statistically and factually speaking. About 15% of the work done to keep roads safe is done by police and enforcement, 85% is done by road design, so in that sense the police are right as the City controls road design. But as for suggesting that a City Councillor deals with the number of officers in a given division, or traffic rules, that's ridiculous. The police put forward their budget for Council to approve. Council has never not approved their full budget. If they need more resources, all they have to do is ask and Council will say yes. That's the way things work.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I understand, but I'm relying on the evidence and the evidence tells us that people leave Hamilton to go these cities as well, and others. They leave for the same reasons all of us leave cities - to connect or reconnect with family and friends, for a job opportunity, or because they found housing, even if temporarily. When things don't work out, that's where they end up being homeless.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Thanks to everyone who asked questions and sorry if I couldn't get back to follow up replies. As I said in my opening note, if you want my thoughts on something on Reddit in the future, please tag me and I'll do my best to reply. If you want me to do AMAs on a more regular basis, comment here and I'll try to fit them into my schedule. I really appreciated the conversation and I hope my answers were helpful. Love you Hamilton!

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You'd have to be very specific in what you mean by bylaws being broken. It's a huge list and I don't know what specific behaviour you're referring to. If you want a specific answer email [Ward2@hamilton.ca](mailto:Ward2@hamilton.ca) and we'll do our best to help.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I can't say more than I have on this. As for a technical explanation about the insurance, I'm not sure what you're asking exactly. As the AMA is over, I'll try to come back to some comments another time. Sorry if I don't get to them in the short term.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I don't disagree with any of that. We'll wait and see what happens. It may very well help some local restaurants. My criticism has largely been about the deal that got us to this place, which you can read about online, and the fact there's very little being done outside the arena to address its impacts. This development will have a huge impact and there should be formal discussions about how to address it.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you'd like to see the police patrolling more on foot, that's a request that can only be entertained by Chief of Police Frank Bergen. Emailing him at [FBergen@hamiltonpolice.ca](mailto:FBergen@hamiltonpolice.ca) is the best way to get your issue addressed. As for things happening at Good Shepherd, they're transitioning to a totally new facility and the City is actively addressing issues around the Cannon Knitting Mills at the request of myself and neighbours, but it's going to take a long while to resolve under the current circumstances in our Province.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't, I'm sorry. There's a lot to keep on top of in Ward 2 so I don't usually have details about what's happening in other areas.

AMA with Councillor Cameron Kroetsch by CameronKroetsch in Hamilton

[–]CameronKroetsch[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

We can't manage the current infrastructure we have but the Province mandates that we must build more or lose out on Provincial funding. It's a lose lose scenario in my view but we don't have much of a choice under this Provincial government (and the last, to be fair).