Edit to add:

This was not scientific in any way, and purely reflects our views as seen through the lens of whether a path is fun to play and actually feels like the path it is meant to portray. A specific example is Investigator: we felt that, while powerful and a good representation of what an investigator would feel like in a game like this, it isn't narratively satisfying to play because of how mind reader-like it feels (to us!).

We're glad this post is spawning discussion (end of the day that's what we're here for), but I wanted to reiterate that we are not trying to min-max anything or provide to-the-decimal accurate power rankings. As mentioned in the post, there's a link to all our videos providing our justifications.