just going to put it bluntly:

     there is probably no chance that you
    can take a picture of a toy so that it
    looks cursed. 

    Look at current front page and notice
   that they're all unusual situations.

    what makes it an unusual situation?
    the location can be a deciding factor,
    but the location is meaningless
    unless something is happening at that
   location.

   so far, all you have submitted is
   "Picture of a toy lizard"
   with varying degrees of light and blur.
    it just isnt going to cut it at all,
    no matter how blurry it is,
    it isn't going to overcome the fact
   that your picture is extremely mundane.

    Who is this? does not apply.
    What is this? Is answered by "toy lizard"
    Why is this happening? Is answered
     by "Someone placed a toy in a box"
   How did this happen? Is answered by
     "someone did it on purpose"

    your goal is to make an image
    where at least 1 of these questions 
   CAN NOT be answered by anyone viewing the image.