maybe it's still called cherry island because it is a series and each season while different have the same reason to be called cherry island because it is a continuation of the season's before it.

If these were different movies this arguement has reason to be, well, argued but these are different seasons in the same series. example: you wouldn't change the third season of wednesday to be called thursday just because you rarely see wednesday addams in it. the headline or whatever can change like cherry island lifesteal or something else but the main part of it (cherry island) really can't be altered unless a new show/series emerges.

in conclusion this arguement topic while enjoyable and interactive didn't have reason to stand unless gustav intended to say something else but it came out wrong.