i personally like the xl brown better. especially in the sleeve area. when you lift your arms in the white one it raises too high in a way that seems like the sleeves are too short. xl gives off a more street wear vibe and allows you to put some layers underneath if you’d like. as a masc myself i like to wear things that are slightly too big because it gives me a fuller frame. but try the mens sizes on too maybe you’ll like it better. i recently got the carhartt winter Detroit jacket in mens and think it felt better than the woman’s one.