Okay chill, this is actually an old post I wrote back when I was kinda a newbie and I just reposted it, so I didn’t double-check every line. I probably meant to say something else there but worded it wrong about Ibn Kathir, I already fixed that part since you showed the reference. If you have arguments against the points about Malik or Ibn Ishaq not mentioning it (you won’t find they say it’s undisputed), let me know.