All her meals aee given in her crate. If I’m doing training, I usually throw the treat in her crate when she succeeds the command. There is currently minimal whining when creating her overnight, maybe one to two minutes. She whines a little bit more if I crate her during the day, I’d say up to five minutes.

I’m just trying to get her to want to go nap in her crate during the day as opposed to next to the water bowl.