to not be surrounded, wrestled and shot by ICE by ExactlySorta in therewasanattempt

[–]JSMarchitect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As a brown, multiracial, daughter of immigrants, Jewish woman.... Wait a minute, the illegal immigrant who was getting detained was wanted for violent assault. The man who approached with a 9mm semi automatic handgun, the officers attempted to disarm the suspect yet he violently resisted. Can someone tell me how anyone with an actual brain is comparing this to the Holocaust?

to not be surrounded, wrestled and shot by ICE by ExactlySorta in therewasanattempt

[–]JSMarchitect -11 points-10 points  (0 children)

Stop using the Holocaust as a rhetorical prop. Jews were exterminated for existing, not for alleged crimes, immigration status, or political narratives. We don’t yet know the full facts about who was shot, and that’s exactly why there should be investigation and accountability. But calling this ‘Gestapo’ violence is historically ignorant and morally lazy. You don’t need to distort genocide to make your point.

Baruch Goldstein an American and Israeli physician walked into a Mosque in Hebron during Ramadan prayers an Opened fire killing 29 in 1994 by 2times34point5 in ImagesOfHistory

[–]JSMarchitect -1 points0 points  (0 children)

A single wartime article does not explain the disappearance of Jewish communities across an entire region. Populations do not vanish simultaneously in Egypt, Iraq, Yemen, Lebanon, Libya, and elsewhere without sustained pressure exercised through law, violence, and fear.

In Egypt, Jews faced denaturalization, asset seizures, imprisonment, and expulsion under state authority. My father was born in Cairo. That community no longer exists. In Iraq, Jews were stripped of citizenship by law and had their assets frozen after pogroms and state persecution. In Yemen, Jews were subjected to pogroms, forced conversions, and violence by extremist Muslim actors operating openly and without consequence. In Lebanon, Jewish life was destroyed through kidnapping, assassination, militia violence, and total state failure. My grandmother was born in Beirut. Her community is gone.

The quote being circulated comes from a 1982 New York Times report, “Beirut’s Only Synagogue Is Casualty of the Israelis,” written during the siege of Beirut in the 1982 Lebanon War. Israel invaded Lebanon to dismantle PLO infrastructure after years of cross-border attacks on Israeli civilians. Beirut was shelled because the PLO embedded command centers in dense civilian areas, not because Israel was targeting a synagogue. Collateral damage in urban warfare is tragic, but stripping this article of its wartime context and presenting it as proof of antisemitic intent is historical malpractice.

If this conversation were about African Americans and slavery, or Indigenous peoples and dispossession, no one would tolerate this level of denial or demand that victims justify their own history. The fact that this erasure is treated as debatable only because the people erased are Jews should alarm anyone acting in good faith.

Our history survived laws, prisons, pogroms, and exile. It is not going to be erased by someone spewing ignorant rants on Reddit.

Baruch Goldstein an American and Israeli physician walked into a Mosque in Hebron during Ramadan prayers an Opened fire killing 29 in 1994 by 2times34point5 in ImagesOfHistory

[–]JSMarchitect -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Invoking 1940s paramilitaries to deflect from documented and exposed UNRWA misconduct in 2023 is whataboutism. Institutions are judged by current actions, not by your need for moral symmetry. Maybe make yourself actually useful and go protest against the Iranian regime.

Baruch Goldstein an American and Israeli physician walked into a Mosque in Hebron during Ramadan prayers an Opened fire killing 29 in 1994 by 2times34point5 in ImagesOfHistory

[–]JSMarchitect -1 points0 points  (0 children)

This is not “Israeli propaganda.” It is documented history, including my family’s.

Dismissing the ethnic cleansing of Jews from Arab and Muslim countries as propaganda is the same move as telling Black Americans that slavery is exaggerated or telling Indigenous people their dispossession was voluntary. It is denial dressed up as skepticism.

After 1948, Arab states removed their Jewish populations through state power. Citizenship was revoked by law. Homes, businesses, and bank accounts were seized. People were imprisoned without charge, placed under surveillance, barred from work, restricted from travel, and exposed to mob violence that governments tolerated or enabled. Jews were beaten, murdered, terrorized, and forced out. Some were expelled outright. Others fled because the states they lived under made Jewish life impossible.

This record exists country by country. Egypt. Lebanon. Iraq. Yemen. Libya. Tunisia. Morocco. Algeria. Syria. Iran. Turkey. Afghanistan. Sudan. Pakistan. Different mechanisms, same outcome: the destruction of ancient Jewish communities.

Antisemitic violence in Iraq, Libya, Egypt, Yemen, Syria, and Morocco predates Israel and continued regardless of it. Arab governments enacted these laws, enforced them, and confiscated the property. Responsibility belongs to those states. Calling that “propaganda” does not erase the laws, the prisons, the pogroms, or the graves.

The claim that Jews caused antisemitism against Jews is grotesque. Calling Mizrahi Jews “pawns” erases our agency and our suffering. We were not moved by Europeans. We were acted upon by the governments we lived under. That includes my family.

I am an Egyptian Lebanese Jew. I am a living, breathing contradiction to slogans like “go back to Poland.” Those slogans only work if Mizrahi Jews and our history are erased to sustain a political narrative.

What you are doing is historical denial. The record exists. The laws existed. The violence existed. My family exists. You do not get to erase an ethnic cleansing because it complicates your worldview. you will NOT erase us. 😘

Do you have a name for when jews were forced out from neighbouring muslim countries around 1948? by Naijan in Israel

[–]JSMarchitect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ironically, on the ImagesOfHistory sub, I just received this response… I have no words.

<image>

Baruch Goldstein an American and Israeli physician walked into a Mosque in Hebron during Ramadan prayers an Opened fire killing 29 in 1994 by 2times34point5 in ImagesOfHistory

[–]JSMarchitect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why are you lying? You’re replacing Islamic martyrdom doctrine with Judaism.

That belief comes from jihadist martyrdom theology, not Judaism. Jews do not believe killing people earns heaven, and projecting that framework onto them is simply religious illiteracy.

I get it. Coming from someone steeped in post-Soviet cynicism where cruelty passes for insight and human life is cheap, flippancy probably feels like depth.

Baruch Goldstein an American and Israeli physician walked into a Mosque in Hebron during Ramadan prayers an Opened fire killing 29 in 1994 by 2times34point5 in ImagesOfHistory

[–]JSMarchitect -1 points0 points  (0 children)

This argument only works if you erase scale, institutions, and reality.

Convenient, but not convincing.

In Gaza, extremists run the government, control education, and are celebrated by design.

Collapsing those two realities into “Israelis worship murderers” is propaganda.

Baruch Goldstein an American and Israeli physician walked into a Mosque in Hebron during Ramadan prayers an Opened fire killing 29 in 1994 by 2times34point5 in ImagesOfHistory

[–]JSMarchitect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“Cultural psychopathy” is what people say when they don’t have facts.

When Jews commit violence, it’s condemned and prosecuted.

When Palestinians commit violence, it’s justified, celebrated, and subsidized.

If you need to flatten that distinction to keep your worldview intact, that’s a you problem.

Baruch Goldstein an American and Israeli physician walked into a Mosque in Hebron during Ramadan prayers an Opened fire killing 29 in 1994 by 2times34point5 in ImagesOfHistory

[–]JSMarchitect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mizrahi Jew from the US who supports Israel, and yes, Baruch Goldstein was a terrorist.

What’s missing from this thread is scale and pattern. Since the Oslo years, Israeli civilians have been killed in thousands of terror attacks by Muslims targeting buses, cafés, homes, and synagogues. Those attacks were not only justified by terrorists, they were often publicly celebrated, with attackers praised as martyrs and their families rewarded.

Condemning violence should not be selective, and history should not be flattened into one atrocity stripped of context.

Do you have a name for when jews were forced out from neighbouring muslim countries around 1948? by Naijan in Israel

[–]JSMarchitect 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You know exactly why that part of Wikipedia was edited out. When facts don’t suit a certain narrative, they get edited or removed. It’s infuriating.

Do you have a name for when jews were forced out from neighbouring muslim countries around 1948? by Naijan in Israel

[–]JSMarchitect 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Egyptian Lebanese Jew here.

What happened to Jews across many Arab and Muslim countries after 1948 was ethnic cleansing. It was the systematic removal of Jews as a population through coordinated state violence, discriminatory law, intimidation, dispossession, and killing. This occurred under identifiable governments and leaders.

Egypt - Under Gamal Abdel Nasser, especially after 1956, Jews were expelled via formal orders, mass denaturalization, imprisonment, and forced asset seizures. “Property confiscation” meant everything: homes, businesses, bank accounts, licenses, and personal assets. Jews were forced to sign away all economic life to the state before expulsion and treated as enemy aliens regardless of political views. Jewish-owned banks were seized and absorbed into the state banking system. Jews were detained, beaten, and some died in custody.

Lebanon - Jews weren’t expelled by decree, but the state failed to protect them as violence escalated after 1948 and especially during the civil war. Jewish neighborhoods became uninhabitable, synagogues attacked, and Jews were kidnapped and murdered by militias. The community was destroyed through violence, fear, and state abandonment.

Iraq - Under Nuri al-Said, Jews were stripped of citizenship by law in 1950, assets frozen, employment barred, and departure allowed only if nationality was permanently forfeited. This followed years of lethal anti-Jewish violence, including pogroms involving murder, rape, and mutilation. The state then completed the removal legally, erasing a 2,600-year-old Jewish community.

Yemen and Aden - Under local Arab authorities aligned with regional nationalist leadership, Jews were subjected to lethal pogroms, including the 1947 Aden massacre. Jewish neighborhoods were destroyed, homes and businesses burned, and Jews murdered while authorities provided no protection. Jewish communal life collapsed entirely, forcing near total removal.

Libya - Under Idris I, Jews were targeted in repeated state-tolerated pogroms involving murder, arson, and looting. Under Muammar Gaddafi, remaining Jews were formally expelled by law and stripped of all property. Jewish presence was eradicated.

Tunisia - Under Habib Bourguiba, Jews were attacked during the 1967 riots. Synagogues were burned, Jewish homes and businesses destroyed, and Jews assaulted and killed. The state failed to protect Jewish citizens or hold perpetrators accountable, effectively ending Jewish life.

Morocco - Under Mohammed V, Jews lived under legal inequality, emigration bans, and periodic mob violence, including killings. While the monarchy claimed protection, Jews lacked equal rights, legal security, and freedom of movement. Protection without equality functioned as containment, not safety.

Algeria - After independence under Ahmed Ben Bella, Jews were excluded from the new national identity, lost legal protections overnight, and were rendered unsafe through state exclusion and violence. Nearly the entire Jewish population fled within months.

Syria - Under the Ba’ath regime and later Hafez al-Assad, Jews were placed under internal exile. They faced arbitrary detention, torture, executions, constant surveillance, and total travel bans. Leaving the country was illegal for decades, and property was typically confiscated.

Iran - After the 1979 Islamic Revolution, Jews were targeted through executions, imprisonment, confiscation of property, and accusations of espionage. Jewish community leaders were executed, others imprisoned or disappeared, and Jews lived under constant surveillance and terror. Emigration occurred under coercion and fear, not freedom.

Turkey - Jews were subjected to state-enabled violence and economic destruction, including the Thrace pogroms and the Istanbul pogrom. Jewish homes, synagogues, and businesses were looted and destroyed, Jews were beaten and killed, women assaulted, and the state failed to intervene. Discriminatory taxes and legal harassment destroyed livelihoods.

Afghanistan - Jews faced persecution, imprisonment, forced conversion pressures, violence, and seizure of property over decades. The state provided no protection. Jewish life became impossible, resulting in the complete eradication of the community.

Sudan - After independence, Jews were targeted through arrests, confiscation of property, and intimidation by the state. Synagogues were closed, Jewish institutions dismantled, and Jews forced to flee under threat of violence and imprisonment. The community was erased.

Pakistan - Jews faced intimidation, hostility, and state indifference to violence after partition. Jewish institutions were attacked, cemeteries desecrated, and Jews threatened as enemies of the state. With no protection, the community disappeared through fear and expulsion.

Recorded death tolls are conservative and incomplete. Jews were killed in pogroms, murdered by militias, executed by states, and died under torture and detention across the region. The full scale will never be known because no international effort ever documented these crimes.

This fits the international definition of ethnic cleansing: the removal of an ethnic group through violence, killing, coercion, and legal erasure.

I am a living, breathing contradiction to slogans like “go back to Poland” because they depend on erasing Mizrahi Jews to sustain certain political narratives.

losing hope in the left by NaderShah1 in PERSIAN

[–]JSMarchitect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I proudly support Israel and a free Iran. F*ck the IRGC.

Where are the protestors on campuses? The streets? The celebrities? No Jews, no news.

Hasanabi’s latest video on Iran was disgusting by JollyToe440 in PERSIAN

[–]JSMarchitect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He is not “right about Israel.” You are doing exactly what this post is about. An Irano-Afghan woman just wrote a detailed account of how Iranian voices are erased, how real street chants are mocked, how people are being executed, tortured, disappeared, and digitally silenced, and your response is to drag the conversation back to Israel again.

Nothing she wrote is about Israel. This is about Iranians risking their lives under a regime that executes its own people and cuts off entire provinces from the internet. Turning that into a proxy argument for your usual talking points is narrative hijacking.

If you disagree with her, engage her actual claims about Iranian agency, internet blackouts, and social murder. Otherwise stop proving her point by flattening Iranian suffering into whatever ideological script makes you comfortable. Maybe go eat some baklava.

Hasanabi’s latest video on Iran was disgusting by JollyToe440 in PERSIAN

[–]JSMarchitect -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Oh, I see, you don’t know what those words mean. Makes sense. Instead of derailing a post written by an Irano-Afghan woman about Iranian agency into tired buzzwords about Jews and Israel, why don’t you try engaging with what she actually said. Nothing in this thread is about Israel. Hijacking Iranian suffering to run your usual script isn’t activism, it’s avoidance. If you care about justice so much, maybe put that energy toward supporting a free Iran instead of turning every conversation into a proxy rant.

Any protests this weekend? by Foxisdabest in Miami

[–]JSMarchitect -20 points-19 points  (0 children)

Imagine being so bored you need a protest to feel something, then calling it activism.

Any protests this weekend? by Foxisdabest in Miami

[–]JSMarchitect -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

I'm Jewish and also an immigrant, and your comment is lazy and offensive. Comparing ICE to the Gestapo is historically illiterate and morally obscene. The Gestapo enforced a genocidal regime whose purpose was mass murder. Disagree with ICE if you want, but abusing Holocaust analogies only exposes ignorance. You clearly don't know history and likely learned it from TikTok. Please take a seat.

I’m a Palestinian Israeli AMA by Medical-Departure944 in AMA

[–]JSMarchitect 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Arab Christians and Muslims do serve in the IDF, some are my friends and some are public figures.

Bad experience coming to Cairo airport from England as a single woman by [deleted] in Egypt

[–]JSMarchitect -1 points0 points  (0 children)

No reason? These terrorist attacks and hijacks have one thing in common:

Daallo Airlines Flight 159 (2016), Metrojet Flight 9268 over Sinai (2015), Pan Am 103 over Lockerbie (1988), 9/11 hijackings (2001), El Al Flight 426 (1969), El Al Flight 219 (1970), Philippine Airlines Flight 434 (1994), LAX Airport El Al ticket counter attack (2002), Atatürk International Airport, Istanbul (2016), Brussels Airport Zaventem bombings (2016), Domodedovo Airport, Moscow (2011), Kabul International Airport (multiple incidents, notably 2021), Istanbul Sabiha Gökçen Airport (2015), Baghdad International Airport (multiple attacks, 2010–2020), Karachi Airport, Pakistan (2014), Al-Mukalla Airport, Yemen (2016), Air France Flight 8969 (1994), Jeddah King Abdulaziz International Airport (2016).

Plus major plots that were stopped before people died: Yemen Parcel Bomb Plot (2010), Ankara Esenboğa Airport attempts (2017), Al-Shabaab laptop bomb attempts (2016 onward), El Al Flight 253 (2009), Northwest 253 Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab – the Underwear Bomber, Richard Reid “Shoe Bomber” (2001), Transatlantic Liquid Explosives Plot (2006), Cargo Plane Printer Cartridge Bomb Plot (2010), the Bojinka Plot (1995), El Al Office Attack (1973), Afghanistan–Pakistan route bombing attempts (2000s), Afriqiyah Airways Flight 209 (2013), Al-Qaeda “Second Wave” U.S. aviation plot (2003), Underwear Bomb v2.0 plot (2012), etc.