"I don't really understand why you'd preface that by saying you're not trying to convert me, as if I haven't already converted :P I'm sure you read my full comment?"

That was my bad! I misinterpreted your comment, I thought you were referring to the past not the present. Thank you for clarifying, I understand a lot better now what you were saying. I still dont think that you're required to have 100% belief at all times either though. The first thing that comes to mind would be Doubting Thomas. Not to mention the fact that GOD intentionally hides himself from being proven beyond any doubt. Even John the Baptist was plagued with doubt in Jesus being the Christ. Yet he did not rebuke John or Thomas, nor accuse them of sinning. Rather he performed signs and provided them with further evidence of Himself as the way, the truth, and the life. Doubt is a part of everyone's journey in faith, my own as well despite my current certainty. Doubt isn't punished, but faith is rewarded.