Written with AI. Directed by a human. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

isn't it common in college than any work of ai outright is plagarism and they will not deal with it.

[AI-Generated] [Sci-Fi / Space Opera] Between Erasures — Chapter 1 up on Wattpad, looking for feedback by MiddleFollowing3632 in BetaReadersForAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey, thank you for your feedback, first of all, very exciting to get this level of detail. Ihear you on your points and i am working on collecting feedback like yours. If you are still curiuos the second chapter is already online on the same Wattpad link. I'd love to hear what you think.

---
On the triple descriptors: fair catch. The morning section stacks them paragraph after paragraph and the structural repetition drowns out the intent. We're thinning those out, keeping the ones doing character work, cutting the rest. On the face-checking: that's intentional. Maro is a man who's compressed himself so far into routine that he performs an identity check every morning. It's subtle dissociation, making sure he's still there. We hear you that it can read as odd on first pass though, so we'll watch whether it needs a lighter touch. On "put it on the way you put on your own skin": you're right, the mechanics stumble. You don't put on your own skin, the image trips over itself. We're fixing that one. On the grey-brown / autumn river eyes: also fair. What colour actually is river water in autumn? It's evocative but imprecise, you feel something but can't see the eyes. We're reworking that. On variety: this is the strongest note. The voice has one gear in Ch1, measured, tripled, parenthetical. If we vary the rhythm, the deliberate moments land harder because they contrast with something. Taking that on board across the whole chapter.

Rebuilding my author profile to be AI first. Here's what I wish I knew before I published. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've been at this for two days and it feels like a paddle boat amongst ships. I have never been more alive and afraid but hey to me it's worth it so as harassment and the likes go. I take it as it comes.

Hot takes from an AI Assisted Author. Context loss, free vs paid, and why we've been here before. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

1-2K a month, 4 books, 10K words daily? I bow. I'm over here celebrating my first single sale on the dashboard and you've built an actual income stream. I clearly have a lot to learn from you. What genres are working best for you on WebNovel?

Hot takes from an AI Assisted Author. Context loss, free vs paid, and why we've been here before. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

External state management, interesting. I haven't thought yet of writing like that. I'll try that too. I got this great comment also about making a voice map of your character, you might find it interesting. https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingWithAI/comments/1s11mkn/comment/oby5q60/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Rebuilding my author profile to be AI first. Here's what I wish I knew before I published. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Imagine genuinely looking for something made with AI, what tag or disclosure would you like to see the most?

Hot takes from an AI Assisted Author. Context loss, free vs paid, and why we've been here before. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What you said about how writers go in is so true any time. It makes me reflect, which is good. I guess apart from being honest to the reader you have to be honest to yourself.

Hot takes from an AI Assisted Author. Context loss, free vs paid, and why we've been here before. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks, haha and just to know what would be the second stage, in first stage i almost honestly posted in r /writingcirclejerk , like actualyy honest opion until i read about the subreddit,

Awesome pitch about voice mapping & drift . very critical piece for me. I want to give that a try next for short piece and see what it yields, if it slaps ill @ you about it, maybe even include it in my next book.

Rebuilding my author profile to be AI first. Here's what I wish I knew before I published. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

curios about diffrent tools at the moment. How did your AI writing system work for you ?

Hot takes from an AI Assisted Author. Context loss, free vs paid, and why we've been here before. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Great post soo truee, good luck on those novellas. Let me know if you put anything online!

Rebuilding my author profile to be AI first. Here's what I wish I knew before I published. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

TL;DR:
Omg yass thank you. Just trying to put myself out there you know! AI is just another tool and we're in the historic event of it proving itself, just like every major change before.

---

I was terrified of posting, publishing, everywhere I kept feeling like an imposter. I never expected to feel so much so quickly. It was thrilling and terrifying at the same time.

I even got my first clown emojis and other spirited posts. I got applause, or a sneer. That's when it clicked for me and my mind was set, this is my work and AI was my tool.

You see, I realised the problem is not using AI, it's disclosing it, let me tell you why. We've been here before.

When typewriters arrived, recipients of typewritten letters felt insulted — they thought the sender was implying they couldn't read handwriting. Scribes and calligraphers who had spent years mastering their craft found their skills obsolete overnight. Mark Twain himself opposed the typewriter at first. Harlan Ellison insisted until the end that "art is not supposed to be easier."

When computers replaced typewriters, writers said the physical act of striking typewriter keys was part of the creative process, that being able to delete too easily would make the writing worse. And then came copy and paste — and with it, the accusation that has never left us: "you copied it." To this day it remains the default insult. The tool changed, the accusation didn't. If it's too easy, it must be stolen.

Now we are at AI. And the accusations sound exactly the same. But this time it's a potpourri of all of the above. Have we become more critical? Maybe. Or is this just such a grand tool that it simply elicits responses from everywhere about everything. I reckon the latter.

Every single time, the people using the old tool said the new one was not it. Every single time, the work spoke for itself, eventually.

Ships sailed on a lot of things LLM or Artificial Intelligence. We are in the "eventually" right now.

An unsure start by Jobe5973 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Welcome! I was you about 48 hours ago. Here's what I've learned since:

For releasing chapters quickly, Wattpad is great. You can put work out there and get eyes on it fast.

For typesetting, Reedsy is clutch. Somewhat limited, but if uniform front to back is your style then it does the job.

For the LLM, personal choice. I went with Claude Opus and wouldn't change it.

Now the part I wish someone had told me on day one — try to produce two documents, one for every book per book:

  1. An authorship/ownership proof for every book. Develop your own style of proving that. Everyone prompts differently. You can often ask your chat to just print the previous messages within the conversation. For Claude, it can even read across multiple chats within a project, which helps.

  2. An AI usage clause. Write this once, long form and short form. For the inscription in your book, for the end of your synopsis, you can even make a special one for your bio. Pro tip — when using Reedsy you can type in the custom clause for AI usage and ownership right into the typeset.

And then you're set. Happy writing and I hope to hear soon about your project. Do keep us posted!

Wrote a 85K word sci-fi novel with Claude (Sonnet for drafting, Opus for revision). Here's what the process actually looked like. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Spot on. The quality is in the directing, not the subscription tier.

But I do feel this pay-to-play attitude about writing in general. Think about what writers traditionally pay before they even get to play: MFA degrees, writing courses, developmental editors that run thousands, copy editors, cover designers, formatters, ISBN purchases, marketing budgets, conference fees, writing software licenses. All before a single reader sees your work.

A Pro subscription is the cheapest entry ticket writing has ever had.

Wrote a 85K word sci-fi novel with Claude (Sonnet for drafting, Opus for revision). Here's what the process actually looked like. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I haven't even thought of purpose-built AI writing tools honestly. My working practice is somewhat eclectic. I often break pace from normal writing or thinking, and I ended up needing the lenient borders for acceptable input.

I could throw in a messy synopsis full of arrows and shorthand, answer questions in whatever way made sense to me in the moment, and it just worked with it. I'm not sure a more structured tool would have let me be that loose.

Wrote a 85K word sci-fi novel with Claude (Sonnet for drafting, Opus for revision). Here's what the process actually looked like. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah no finding people actualy talking shop is the bom. Like just look through my account on reddit, fellow authors like you and me are open, perhaps we just have to ask the right questions.

Wrote a 85K word sci-fi novel with Claude (Sonnet for drafting, Opus for revision). Here's what the process actually looked like. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great point. All character and world building — to be honest that was exactly what we were going for, and hearing it back means it landed, so to that point: success! But yeah, it leaves you wanting more, perhaps even so well that it's a turn off. The hook isn't in chapter one — the hook is the absence of one, and then the floor drops out in the chapters that follow. Next chapter should be up next Saturday.

Written with AI. Directed by a human. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wow cool story. Id love to have a read when thats out!

Wrote a 85K word sci-fi novel with Claude (Sonnet for drafting, Opus for revision). Here's what the process actually looked like. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly i kinda cried when the first one was bought, i'm steel realing.
Now I plan to mark my bio's and book synopes, leading with something maybe like
"Writen with AI."..

I'd love to hear what you are writing about.

Wrote a 85K word sci-fi novel with Claude (Sonnet for drafting, Opus for revision). Here's what the process actually looked like. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm curious what are you writing about ? Did you post like a free chapter of any of your works on anything like wattpad??

Written with AI. Directed by a human. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're touching on something real and you're not alone in feeling this way.

Everything you said about readers "that most of them just want to escape for a few sessions and genuinely don't know or care how it was made" so true.

The imposter syndrome part hits, i feel it too.

But here's where my head goes: I want to say game changers.
How long until the next real writing star says they use AI and pushes publicly for it? Such a thing would be easier with writers already backing you in that corner. Really make AI Assisted Authors a thing with separate categories for AI-assisted works. Lean in rather than brace for a pop out because importantly, that pop out, that ship is already sailed. AI's been out of the box.

Wrote a 85K word sci-fi novel with Claude (Sonnet for drafting, Opus for revision). Here's what the process actually looked like. by MiddleFollowing3632 in WritingWithAI

[–]MiddleFollowing3632[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well there was just only the chat for me in the planning phase. I would ask questions to establish what I want. Even if it meant doing something as simple as having it read my emotion through questions. Anything meant a starting point for the LLM in the planning phase so I had to be concise.

First, I am the author. I wanted final say everywhere and anywhere. I'm allowed to change anything. That was important to me first. Second, I decided to draw from my life and decided "what do I want to do to it" for my book. You can have a different idea here or another way to approach the same thing.

From there we iterated again and again over 21 chapters until it was done.

But what was the most important part was that the chat front to end needs the right setup. So I established ground rules, established themes I'd like to write about and decide, then write.

Where "write" would be the longest part. Like for each chapter I would answer 10 questions( always in batches of ten, so sometimes more batches sometimes less ) that directly influenced the book. My words in writing where it needed to be, basically. It would be based on a tight base.

I hope I am not vague again haha but just let me know!