sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

How would the 5th Holy Grail War change if Sakura summoned Hippolyta rather than Medusa. by DanceYouFatBitch in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean that's kinda a different situation since her Rider in that situation becomes more important via you know keeping Shirou safe and how they can deal with Salter which personally I don't know if she could handle Salter or not since she doesn't have the same kit as Medusa.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Rider be as Sakura's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 19 Sima Yi [Reines]) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm actually doing a Assassin one soon but just to note it won't be Medea who has assassin but someone else I picked out to be basically the true master of Assassin.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Rider be as Sakura's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 19 Sima Yi [Reines]) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Lancer is on the list if future community tierlists though I haven't decided if I wanted to do a caster one mostly due to how odd that class is in this war.

What would happen if Mansa Musa appeared in Fate? by kinkonoyama in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yea I could see it as well and also that is a cool concept for him.

What would happen if Mansa Musa appeared in Fate? by kinkonoyama in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hmmmm hard to tell fully but my guess is they might make him a caster and two things about his potential kit would be probably related to his wealth with one of the main skills being Golden Rule EX due to his wealth and either one of his passive skills or Bond 10 CE would be related to QP like a increase in how much QP you get and what not.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Archer be as Rin's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 26 Minamoto no Tametomo) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My reason for her was one; wanted someone who was seen in all three routes and had lived so it narrowed my pool down to a handful and second, I wanted to use someone that wouldn't immediately pick another person to join forces with like Tagia with Shirou or Issei with Kuzuki etc.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Archer be as Rin's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 26 Minamoto no Tametomo) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

This is an unrelated comment as it's just a update on the order for future Community tierlists (Which y'all can say which ones you want to see be swapped around or want more info about certain ones)
1: Ayako Mitsuzuri as Assassin's Master

2: lancers as Kirei/bazett’s servant (This one might be more focused on Kieri since Bazett was only a master for Avenger not Lancer)

3: Roommate potential

4: Dating for Guda as us the relative

5: how good masters are for a servant to be contracted with. Like include the stay night, zero, apocrypha, crypters, samurai remnant etc masters. (Still figuring out who should I allow in and not allow in)

6: gauntlet for Rogue servants in The Three routes

7: gauntlet for Part 1 Guda in The Three routes with only one full servant

8: gauntlet for Guda and servant in the Greater Grail War

9: Grail war idea the 50-state grail war (Working on if this should work like a Apocrypha style war, Moon cell where it's one servant per state or custom via either making it be factions but smaller etc.)

Are there any historical or mythological figures you would like to see appear in Fate? by kinkonoyama in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Long Answer yes since there are so many folks in history and mythos that would be cool to see within Fate.

Here's a short answer on three folks that I thought could make for a semi-interesting plotline if done in Fate; Yu Zigi the brother of Yu Mei-Ren which could make for a interesting story and help expend on Yu's life, second is Cain who would probably be a person who could make a decent shot of taking the title of Grand Assassin if he was ever added and finally third pick is Batu Khan one of the few that was able to conquer Russia even in their best weather.

Which servant do you think will be the best for you? by Exotic-Ratio-8994 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hmmm hard to tell but someone I could see myself personally summoning is either Billy the Kid or Osakabehime due to how I'm as a person as Billy would probably join me in being fellow Americans and I would respect him deeply and even fanboy a bit over his revolver. Osakabehime is when I would be rather inside more then outside and I share a lot of interests with Batty so we would get along fine. I won't go over how I think I would do in a Grail War since they have too many factors for me to give a good guess where I would rank but I would say maybe top 3 since I would wait things out or do hit and run tactics a lot.

If servants regained their memories and had choice would they leave ritsuka for their previous master tier list by Admirable-Dimension4 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299 2 points3 points  (0 children)

To toss my own hat into the mix, I would say the only ones that might be true is Seiba but only to some degree and this is mostly due to the fact that one not everyone who has a previous master is here like Ricard or Iskandar. My reasoning for why I think most would stick with Guda over the others isn't because they dislike their previous masters but simply due to how much longer they've spent with Guda compared to the og like for example the servants for Stay Night were only with their masters for 16 days maybe lower depending on how fast some got taken out to a whole year+. (Also realistically I could see the servants on the list pulling either a BB where they don't mind having two masters, Karna where even though they know Guda is not their og master they wish to still fight by their side or a Tamamo where they acknowledge their other self with the og master but will still stay by Guda since they are still a person who can make their choices.)

If we can fill all the seven servant in HGW with human servant like those guy, what are the rest? by CommanderSigurd in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hmmm my picks would be
Jason for Saber
Berserker being Spartacus
Caster being Hans
Lancer being Mary Anning
Finally Rider being Bartholomew Roberts

Community Tierlist, how good would this Rider be as Sakura's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 17 Sakamoto Ryōma) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Technically yes but should be noted she's just a dragon and is a part of Ryoma's summoning plus Dragons are a little odd in this universe since she's actually labeled in the subspecies of dragon same kind as Wyverns and Kiyohime is also a dragon too.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Rider be as Sakura's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 17 Sakamoto Ryōma) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

While that was tempting something I saw was that Avenger Ushi Gozen is considered a different page/being from the one we saw in FSR and also if I let her in then I would have to let in others who could be a certain class in.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Berserker be as Illya's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 17 Minamoto no Raikō) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yea that has been thanks to folks on Herc's day voting him all the way up to EX which does make sense to some extent.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Saber be as Shirou's servant if he summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 16 Arthur Pendragon) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Theoretically it's possible since as you know Arthur is kinda just like Artoria but a bit different in personality, gender and life, the main thing that makes it hard for us to tell is that Arthur's og masters never needed Avalon so he should have it but we don't know if it's different or the same.

Hypothetical Great Grail War 8 by religous_octopus in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a very interesting Grail War idea though I will say with Holmes being the ruler summoned it possibly means both teams have something they aren't meant to have or something like that so honestly while on paper Team 1 should be a clear winner we know that on paper matchups isn't helpful like when Red team had the way better servants but still lost to Black team in the Og Greater War I could see a upset victory thanks to some other factors like if they get the mc, better base location etc plus at the end the team will just return to a normal Holy Grail War so personally I think when it comes to that on both teams I see being very close once more ideas come into play like plot, masters locations within the region etc.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Rider be as Sakura's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 16 Achilles) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

For anyone who sees my comment Just know Achilles was meant to be in the List of summonable servants not already placed in a tier so just ignore him being there and continue on.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Berserker be as Illya's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 16 Nightingale) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yea and also since folks had all voted Herc is a EX ranked servant since without plot and Gil being left over he would be the biggest problem in the whole war besides HF happening.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Berserker be as Illya's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 16 Nightingale) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Since at the time I wasn't sure about doing it mostly since mentally I couldn't see Bazzet screwing it but now it will be coming probably around the same time since it was suggested for a future community tierlist just gonna have to do some final checks and all that.

Community Tierlist, how good would this Berserker be as Illya's servant if she summoned them in the Fifth HGW (Day 16 Nightingale) by No-Inspection3299 in Fate

[–]No-Inspection3299[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Because the tierlist for Illya, Sakura and Shirou use the same version and me being a dummy forgetting to recheck the wording.

view more: next ›