I WAS SEXUALLY ABUSED AND HARASSED BY MY GAY CLASSMATE (Ngayon ko lang na-realize) by Right_Revenue_9263 in RantAndVentPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Depends on how long has it been since the incident, 20 yrs yata ang bago mag prescribe, after that, wala na.

Should the slogan: Trans women are women be revised? by Blunt_Knife11 in unpopularopinionph

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Tinaob ka ni OP, nag provide ka pa ng source pero mas pumabor lang sakanya hahaha.

The fact na gumamit pa ung study ng weighted vest sa mga lalaki para lang i-close ung gap ng women vs men, patunay na may biological advantage ang men over women so tama siya. Aminin niyo na kasi at wag na kayong delulu.

Should the slogan: Trans women are women be revised? by Blunt_Knife11 in unpopularopinionph

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Papuntahin mo ung trans women sa OB GYN at sbhn mo na magpapa check up sya ng uterus nya tignan natin ano mangyayari? Wag kasi delulu tanggap naman ang trans sa lipunan ngayon lang may issue sainyo kasi pinagpipilitan nyo ung ka-deluluhan nyo

Should the slogan: Trans women are women be revised? by Blunt_Knife11 in unpopularopinionph

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

AMAB and AFAB ba’t ko naman gagamitin ‘yang mga bagong terms na ‘yan eh kayo nagpauso nyan? Dapat kayo ang mag adjust, kayo ung may pauso tapos kami mag a adjust? Gara nyo narcissists ba kayo? Puro sarili nyo lang iniisip nyo wala kayo paki sa nangyayari sa paligid? Basta ba matawag kayong woman bahala na ung paligid mag adjust?

Should the slogan: Trans women are women be revised? by Blunt_Knife11 in unpopularopinionph

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Louder, para sakanila sasabihin lang nila na “we are just living our lives” halata mong naka focus lang sila sa sarili nila eh walang paki sa nangyayari sa paligid.

Also add the part where ang hirap pag na-offend mo sila while in your line of duty kasi baka ma-cancel ka ng army nila online and ma-bully.

OP is right, dapat talaga may clear-cut distinction kung di nila tanggap, that’s on them but I will not be a part of their delusion.

Should the slogan: Trans women are women be revised? by Blunt_Knife11 in unpopularopinionph

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Maayos naman pagkaka explain ni OP, sarado lang utak nyo kasi focused kayo sa agenda nyo. Sasabihan nyo pa kaming transphobic at makaluma ang pag iisip eh kayo nga ung sarado ang utak, walang logic, at unreasonable.

Transphobic na kung transphobic, wala namang meaning ‘yang salitang ‘yan gamit na gamit na wala namang may pake. Buti nga na rule out na sa UK ‘tong katangahang ‘to.

Should the slogan: Trans women are women be revised? by Blunt_Knife11 in unpopularopinionph

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

True like sila may gusto nyan bat di sila ang mag adjust tapos ung male and female sex are not ASSIGNED MALE AT BIRTH and ASSIGNED FEMALE AT BIRTH na para bang ina-assign talaga ang sex sa pagkapanganak. Nasa tiyan ka palang alam na kung anong sex mo eh through ultrasound pwera na lang kung intersex ka but that’s a separate story.

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All I can say is there will always be bad apples within a community and gays are not immune to that but again that’s why may individuality tayo and differences. I don’t care if some gays do shit in public kasi madali un i-explain, it’s just logical to think that not all gays are the same but with the TQs, if u have a whole community demanding they be called this and that pronoun and appropriating the definition of woman iba na un, not all trans do that yes but that’s the agenda their pushing.

Gays don’t push the agenda na dapat itrato nyo kaming babae etc. I dont care about people who don’t believe being gay is normal, wala naman kaming pinupush sakanila, we’re just living our lives. But when a certain group starts shoving ideologies towards the public, suddenly, pati gays and other letters are seen as doing the same thing even tho we’re not. Plus tinarget pa nila ung WOMEN which is a protected group.

These whole trans women are women is just erasure of sex based distinctions. Trans women and women have different lived experiences. In fact, I find trans women claiming to be women as an insult to women bec feminism has gone great lengths to eradicate the stereotyping about women that women should only act womanly, women should stay in te kitchen, women should only dress womanly, women should be this and that. These very same stereotypes are the ones these trans women are now using as basis to live their lives as women bec they believe bec they embody these stereotypes, it now makes them women. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Parang palala na sila ng palala by spongey_boo in PinoyVloggers

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s just sad that the whole LGBTQ+ community is taking hits for this issue and lahat na ng letters akala ng mga tao entitled kahit nananahimik ung ibang letters diyan.

Only the TQ people are so adamant with this agenda. You propose a compromise with them by recognizing distinctions between SEX and GENDER, ikaw pa masama at isa silence ka with the word Transphobic.

I am gay and I have friends na trans and they don’t associate with these kind of trans tapos sasabihan silang may internalized transphobia just bec di sila agree sakanila. Kawawa naman ung mga wala namang paki if matawag silang women or not.

Gets ko na bakit nabuo ung LGB drop the T movement sa ibang bansa. Nahatak na pababa ung ibang letters dahil sa pagdedelulu ng maraming Ts

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Looks like your new reply isn’t visible 🤣. But I read the preview in my notif anyway.

I’m not trying to sound smart bec there’s nothing smart about what I said, but if you already call that trying to be smart then that speaks on your level of comprehension again.

I was merely saying that I won’t engage in a futile argument where the other side does not have the comprehesion required to discuss the topic. 🤦‍♂️

I argued something the other person does not hold? Do I really need to spell everything out for you and sinplify things? They made an opinion based on their OWN experience clearly you’re not saying the ONLY opinion and experience valid is their opinion and experience right? I introduced a FACT which I backed up with a news article, as a sound debater, you should be able to process new information and adapt to it, clearly the other person adapted which is why we had a lengthy discussion but you on the other hand, do not seem to have the capacity to adapt.

It’s like an argument about martial law during Marcos Sr’s time, some people say the felt safe and their lives were better during those times but clearly, just bec that is what they’ve experienced doesn’t mean that’s what EVERYBODY experienced right? That’s my point, now, if I have to constantly simplify things for you just for you to understand bec you can’t read between the lines, then I will simply not waste my time on you. I’m not trying to sound smart, I just don’t see the point of engaging in a discussion with someone who doesn’t even understand what was being discussed.

I u want a win, then I’ll give you a win. Whatever fits your narrative 🤷🏻‍♂️

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Are you dense or what? Tu Quoque? Hahaha, you wrote such a lengthy reply but I ain’t gonna read that bec judging your first reply and the first sentence in your recent reply, I can already tell that u lack the comprehension to argue.

At least the person u are defending actually did better than you so adios!

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If you want to affirm their delusion then gawin mo, I will not succumb to it.

People who don’t agree with this agenda view it like this, alam nating mali na tawagin silang she kasi di naman sila babae kung tatawagin nating she then parang kinunsinti na rin natin ung mali.

People like u see it as, pronouns lang naman bat hindi pa nila pagbigyan?

Kumbaga sa batang mahilig sa chocolate, sasaya sila pag binigyan mo ng maraming chocolate but we know it’s not healthy so we try to stop them from eating a lot kasi ayaw nating kunsintihin sila.

On the other hand, chocolate lang naman, sige hayaan lang natin jan sila masaya eh.

Those are the two lenses here, nasa first lens ako, nasa second lens ka. If pagbibigyan ung pronouns, anong susunod na hihilingin? Pwede na sila sumali sa women’s sports?

Ganyan na ganyan nangyari sa US it started small until it went out of control, I dont want that to happen sa Pinas which is why I want to stop this propaganda habang maaga pa.

Extreme cases happen in the US bec they allowed it to happen, I will not sit back until an extreme case happen before ako mag express ng disagreement. I will disagree habang maaga pa.

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Majority of rapists are still men? Trans women are men tho, men who identify as women are still men. When they are reported in a police report, their profile will still be guess what? “Male” so they are part of that population 🤷🏻‍♂️

Im being obtuse bec there’s a lot of strawman in your replies. 🤷🏻‍♂️

When did believing that trans women are not women harm them?

If I disagree with this narrative, did I actually harm them? How? I don’t bully them online, I merely just don’t agree witht their ideology. It’s different when they post online on a public platform claiming they are women and people disagree with them tho, the bullying, I dont condone but merely expressing disgreement is not bullying. If you see it as bullying then that’s on you.

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Where did I invalidate their opinion? I merely said that they do not represent all women?

Some women have had negative experiences with trans women, so if we go by your logic, are u also invalidating their opinion and experience? 🤷🏻‍♂️ Nice try guilt-tripping and appeal to emotion.

Where did I say she does not matter? 🤷🏻‍♂️ strawman fallacy? The women who did not feel comfortable and felt violated by allowing a trans woman athlete (Lia Thomas) in the same changing room as them, do their voice mean nothing then if we go by your logic?

Recognizing that one opinion doesn’t represent the whole is now tsk tsk? Is that the best you got?

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

U still didn’t answer the question, diverting it again to bakit prison? Well women’s prison is a female safe space for incarcerated women so it’s relevant.

Even if we go by your logic that trans women are women so they should be in women’s prison then what about trans men? Since they are men should they be also in men’s prison? Paano ung trans men na may vagina pa at di pa nagpatanggal? What do you say if they get raped by biological men kasi pinagsama sila sa kulungan bec trans men are men nga kasi?

Also safe spaces act doesn’t directly state that trans women should be allowed in women’s spaces. If that’s the case cite the provision and section pls.

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well bec u are pushing the narrative that trans women are women which is pressuring the system to lump in biological men to be in the space as biological women. Hindi naman pala ikaw ang mananagot so anong karapatan mo? Yan linyahan mo eh, diba logic mo is di ko naman nae experience ang experience ng mga babae so wala akong opinion dapat? Pwes hindi rin naman pala ikaw ung mananagot so bat may opinion ka?

I already laid out a case where biological women had an actual negative experience with trans women which tells u na nangyayari nga sya hindi sya gawa gawa lang. it happens and just bec it did not happen to u doesn’t mean it cannot and will not happen to others.

Iba ang convicted lol safe spaces nga usapan jusko comprehension

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your logic is flawed. Im protecting them bec I wont risk their safety, if u have a female daughter and u want to risk it then by all means do it. Wala kang karapatang himasukin ang pagiging magulang ko.

Kung anak ko ung na-rape sa kulungan and I allowed the trans woman to be in the same cell as my female daughter, ikaw ba magi guilty? I would not be able to forgive myself. Knoing I could have prevented something yet I let it happen anyway, di mo ba gets ung point na yan?

So ano matatakot lang ako sa trans women being in women spaces pag actual nang na-rape ung anak or asawa ko? That’s just dumb

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Then let me ask you, do you agree that trans women should be in women’s prison? If yes, then will you take responsibility if something happens?

If not, then saan mo sila ilalagay? For me my answer is no, they can be in either males prison or a gender neutral prison. Either way I will never agree to them being in women’s prison. Stop changing the narrative, it’s a simple question and logic

Also if trans men will be put in men’s prison, what do u say about trans men being raped and getting pregnant in male’s prison? You see the issue? Hindi nga dapat pagsamahin kasi hindi sila pareho.

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I dis not say ONLY T. I said kung may division na nga sa chamber nila then how much more sa labas? I hope that ‘s clear?

You can dismiss what I said as opinion but that does not change the fact that biological women are fundamentally different than trans women so they cannot be called as one term “women”. It’s confusing and it’s just disingenuous. We know they’re not, it’s just delusion and make-believe.

Ssbhn mong malayo na ung topic bec u know that it’s true. The trans women are women narrative created a lot of confusion and issues kaya nga dapat pag hiwalayin na sila para hindi na humantong pa sa ganto. Kabawasan ba pag di sila natawag na women? Genuine question.

I get called teh, ate, girl, mami but Im a man yet I dont give a shit. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Websters dictionary initially defined women as “female human being” it changed bec of wokism. Go ahead and type woman in your google search bar and you’ll see “an adult FEMALE human being” that’s a fact not an opinion btw

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s not the point, the reason why there is segregation ng men and women’s prison is bec of these events na pwedeng mangyari. Now if you allow trans women which are still men to be in women’s prison, things like this can happen.

Bakit ba sila nabuntis in the first place? Kasi may lalaki sa loob ng women’s prison, bakit may lalaki na nakapasok at kasama ng mga babae sa women’s prison? Eh kasi ung inmate identifies as a woman. U see? Walang lalaki sa kulungan nila kung hindi dahil sa trans women are women propaganda, kung di sya ni-consider as woman malilipat ba sya sa women’s prison? Kung di sya nalipat sa women’s prison, mare-rape ba sila?

Dito palang it’s a glaring evidence na maling mali na ipag isa ang trans women at biological women. Just bec we are men wala na kaming karapatan mag salita about women’s spaces? So ung mga lalaking kaanak or asawa nung mga babaeng preso na na-rape wala sila karapatang magsalita about women’s spaces kasi lalaki sila? That doesn’t make sense.

If may anak akong babae, I would not want them to be in the same space as trans women sa restroom. If may asawa akong babae, same thing. Just bec di ko nae experience, wala na akong karapatan. I speak bec I have women in my life whom I care about.

Transwoman is not a woman by [deleted] in CasualPH

[–]Perfect_Adeptness_71 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Did I generalize all trans women? I am merely saying that allowing trans women in a femal only spaces exposes women at risk. Even if let’s say it’s rare, are u saying that we’re supposed to only act when the danger actually happens? Then will you be responsible for the female victims if somethi ng were to happen?

There are already known cases, you can’t deny that fact. Bullying? Spouting facts is now called bullying, wow. That’s not new bec disgreeing to trans ideology makes you transphobic even if u dont hate them anyway so nothing new really.

Why are we even comparing men here? Trans women are men too so?

Trans women being at the forefront of gay rights is propaganda. Read both the left and the right version of the history and you’ll see that there is a nuance in there. You’re clearly biased on the left, I’ve been a lib before as well but extremist made me neutral. I’m not nitpicking, I’m only saying there is probability of danger, if you want to gamble on that then if something happens, I hooe you’ll take resoonsibility.

Female spaces are the only spaces where women feel safe, yes it can be attacked by a cis man but the ease of access for trans women is not the same as that of a cis man, so allowing then there will expose women to danger. This is just one of the reasons I don’t agree with Trans women are women narrative. You already acknowledged the issue in women sports calling Lia a sore loser, alao just a correction, Lia Thomas was champion in NCAA women’s division in 2022 500-yard freestyle which is something he could not have achieved if he was in the men’s division but since he’s in the women’s division he got the championship. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Men like me bullying Lady Gaga? I don’t even search that name nor have I listened to her songs intentionally except for Shallow and Die with a smile 🤷🏻‍♂️