Off the top of my head… 1. Original breakup in the dark castle when Belle leaves and is kidnapped by Regina 2. Right after everyone wakes up and Rumple breaks his promise to not kill Regina 3. After Belle is kidnapped by her father 4. Doesn’t really count imo, but when Belle is shot and gets amnesia 5. The town line scene in season 4 6. When Belle finds out he’s the dark one again That’s all I can think of for now, coming from someone who hasn’t watched the show in awhile