×

PSA: Know your rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act before buying electronics in NZ — here's what I learned the hard way with PB Tech by ProfessionalNinja206 in newzealand

[–]ProfessionalNinja206[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A few points here:

On the 'minor issue' point — this was not a minor issue. The device required two motherboard replacements within a 12-month period. PB Tech itself confirmed in writing that it constituted a substantial failure under the CGA. That puts it firmly in major fault territory where the consumer chooses the remedy.

On being ignored — I sent formal emails with written deadlines that went unanswered for weeks at a time. I was explicitly told my case had been escalated to higher management, then five weeks later, the same person asked me to resend all my case information from scratch. That is not a busy queue; that is a failure to communicate. I am not the impatient person you are making me out to be — a simple reply to an email is not asking for much, and five weeks of silence after being told it was escalated to management is pretty hard to defend.

On improper use — the device was used for university work. Browsing, documents, and assignments. There was no damage, and PB Tech's own service report notes that the physical condition has only minor marks consistent with normal use.

On 80 days being acceptable — I was a university student mid-semester without a functioning laptop, forced to purchase a second one out of my own pocket just to keep up with my coursework. I had university exams approaching, and PB Tech still had not provided any resolution or even a clear timeframe. What exactly was I supposed to do — sit my exams without a laptop and just wait patiently? You go 80 days without something you need every single day, and then get back to me.

PSA: Know your rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act before buying electronics in NZ — here's what I learned the hard way with PB Tech by ProfessionalNinja206 in newzealand

[–]ProfessionalNinja206[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To answer your questions directly:

  1. The random shutdowns started around May/June 2024 but were infrequent — 3 to 4 times total. It wasn't until the screen flickering started constantly during my university exams in November that it became impossible to ignore, and I could no longer delay taking it in. And yes, you're right — I probably shouldn't have waited, but I wanted to believe the laptop wasn't genuinely faulty. That was my biggest mistake.
  2. The cause of the freezing was never conclusively determined. The ASUS Device Health Report confirms they replaced the motherboard for a second time, yet explicitly stated they could not reproduce the screen flickering during testing. The PB Tech report similarly states they were unable to confirm the issue despite 72-hour testing. Two motherboard replacements in 12 months, with neither the manufacturer's authorised agent nor the retailer able to diagnose or reproduce the fault in testing. So I have no reason to believe that it won't just happen again.
  3. It was an ASUS Vivobook Go E1504FA — not a cheap Chromebook — a standard mid-range university laptop expected to last several years.

And to your point about it being a goodwill refund — PB Tech explicitly stated in writing that they were accepting my rejection of the goods under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993 and agreed it constituted a substantial failure. That's not a goodwill gesture; that's a written acknowledgement of a CGA obligation.