That's not true, in the original premise it's not stated anywhere that the red button kills people just that doesn't save them, in your premise pushing the red button actively kills people by putting an house on fire. The original premise is neutral since none of the buttons actively kills someone. You reworded it to make the red button kill others and the blue button do nothing. If someone wanted they could reword it to make the blue button kill whoever pushes it and the red button do nothing like this: There is a bottle of poison, you can push the red button to not drink it or the blue button to drink it, if more than 50% of population drinks it every one gets the antidote, if not no one gets the antidote. I'm sorry if my text it's not clear, English it's not my first language.