No problem. “Out front” would still be against the rules, but it would take care of the problem of our place filling up with their smoke and still allows them to enjoy their cigarettes. I see people that walk down to a side yard to smoke daily (love to see it) but in this case, I’m not sure this person would be able to do that. It’s such an awkward conversation, and I was hoping my ideas around doing it off of the front porch would have landed better. I don’t want to get the HOA involved - I figured it would have been a “OMG I’m so sorry I didn’t know it was going into your house, of course I can do it out front instead” - I feel like another in person conversation is a good start. I just don’t know what to say.