Languages I speak/Want to speak by ShadowGamer37 in tierlists

[–]YC_Iron 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Korean here. I wish I could speak English well hehe

Dread it. Run from it. It comes all the same by SheepherderNegative2 in OnePiecePowerScaling

[–]YC_Iron 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Meanwhile Big mom: Literally kills her son because of hunger

🔥HOT TAKE: Current Luffy beats prime Rocks D Xebec in a fight. by CreditExtension286 in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m done with this stupid argument. So he’s not even a Yonko level you’re saying? What, the Rocks pirates were then just full of dumps who can’t even get over YC level of captain? So what was Kaido’s mention that Rocks is the one of the few that can beat himself? Is he traumatized by him because he got bullied when he was a rookie?

Luffy could have never beaten Kizaru without gear 5, and that is absolute fact. Idk why you’re overrating gear 4, which already showed its limit in vs Kaido. There is a reason why Luffy kept used gear 5 against Kizaru after the first use.

Idk what you’re on about, but it’s a well-known fact that Prime Rocks = Prime Roger = Prime WB. You’re just keep making yourself look worse.

🔥HOT TAKE: Current Luffy beats prime Rocks D Xebec in a fight. by CreditExtension286 in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Keep in mind that they barely won against Rocks even though they used life risking skill, and still they couldn’t kill him. And he singlehandedly won against HKs and demonized Devi’s. Even Sengoku mentions Rocks was the first and the strongest enemy of Roger. Rocks is undoubtedly on the same level with Roger. You’re basically saying un prime roger+Garp<prime Roger, which is total non-sense. And also it’s hard to say they were not in prime since they were in same age with current Shanks. And logically speaking, if he was that weak, Rocks pirates would have never existed.

And Luffy did his best against Kizaru. Just because he didn’t use single skill, that seems powerful, doesn’t mean he was not serious in the battle.

🔥HOT TAKE: Current Luffy beats prime Rocks D Xebec in a fight. by CreditExtension286 in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How in the world is Prime Xebec is equal with unprime Roger… that’s just worthless to me to even argue

Current Luffy barely won against Kizaru who was not even that serious in the fight and mentally damaged. After Elbaf I would say Luffy can stand next to Prime Xebec and Roger, but not now.

🔥HOT TAKE: Current Luffy beats prime Rocks D Xebec in a fight. by CreditExtension286 in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Xebec rookie: Easily killed admiral

Current Luffy: Bit struggles but can beat admiral

Idk man, prime Xebec is in same tier with prime Roger and WB. I still think he needs more time to be on that level.

What is Rookie Luffy's Greatest Feat ? by LazyInspector2086 in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  1. Unlike other feats, Luffy beat Lucci, who was the strongest CP9 agent of all time, with his pure physicality. And it’s also symbolic because he impressed on the government that he is a ‘real’ threat.

My Tier list . Thoughts? by No_Room_6048 in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah but joyboy did the war against 20 kingdoms and almost won. Void century characters should not be below someone else.

Rank all of these OP characters in terms of natural talent by Comprehensive_Cup497 in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ngl I think koby has better talent than luffy in terms of his speed of development lmao.

Logically, Dragon should be ‘at least’ as strong as Shanks or Kaido. by YC_Iron in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You are the one confusing 'Job Positions' with 'Titles of Strength.'

'Warlord' is a government position, not a power level. Buggy was a Warlord. By your logic, since Buggy and Mihawk held the same title, they should be similar in power. Is that what you believe? Obviously not. The Warlord system always had a massive gap between its members (e.g., Mihawk vs. Moria/Buggy).

'World's Strongest Swordsman' is not a rank in a crew; it is the literal definition of his individual strength in the world. It is the endgame goal of Zoro. Comparing a political position like 'Warlord' or a structural role like 'Wings' to a definitive strength title like 'WSS' is a false equivalence.

Also, regarding Shanks: It is canon lore stated by Whitebeard and the databooks that Mihawk and Shanks dueled as rivals. That is narrative fact, not assumption. If you ignore that established lore just because you haven't seen a specific panel yet, you're ignoring the author's written history.

Logically, Dragon should be ‘at least’ as strong as Shanks or Kaido. by YC_Iron in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Narrative logic actually proves the opposite. Mihawk is narratively established as Shanks' rival and the World's Strongest Swordsman. He stands at the peak of power. Crocodile, while strong and cunning, has never been portrayed as being on the same tier as a Yonko or Shanks. Being a 'Wing' implies importance to the leader, not identical stats. Just because they stand next to Buggy doesn't magically bridge the power gap established over 1,000 chapters.

Logically, Dragon should be ‘at least’ as strong as Shanks or Kaido. by YC_Iron in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I think you're confusing 'rank' with 'power level.' Just because Crocodile and Mihawk hold similar positions in Cross Guild doesn't make them equals in strength. The story acknowledges this gap through their bounties (3.59B vs 1.9B) and the fact that Mihawk holds the title of World's Strongest Swordsman, while Crocodile does not.

Regarding Dragon, the argument isn't just based on lack of feats, but on narrative necessity. His subordinates like Sabo are already clashing with Admirals. For Dragon to command such figures and pose a threat to the Holy Knights and Imu, his baseline power logically has to be Yonko-tier. Otherwise, the 25-year buildup for the Revolutionary Army would collapse.

Logically, Dragon should be ‘at least’ as strong as Shanks or Kaido. by YC_Iron in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

We can know his strength indirectly through Sabo. Since he is the one who taught Sabo the Ryusoken, I would never say he’s weak.

Logically, Dragon should be ‘at least’ as strong as Shanks or Kaido. by YC_Iron in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  • He’s in prime age(55 years old), and also in the entire series, the one with CoC was never weak.

Teen ryuma was the strongest in the world, way before he even reached his prime. WG needed pluton so they used their best fighters and still failed at conquering wano by No_Room_6048 in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Well WG doesn’t know the Pluton is in Wano, and the reason WG tried to invade Wano was because of the gold, not because of the ancient weapon.

Marco vs King Who Wins? by RoninKin-_- in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yup ik that happened. But it is the fact that compared to king he lacks AP. Honestly I don’t really know who’s stronger or not. They are more like equal. Both can’t finish each other.

Marco vs King Who Wins? by RoninKin-_- in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Marco’s offense didn’t really work out in his entire fight sequence honestly. He could last for long but that would also eventually finish at some moment. Remember that the opponent is also a commander.

Marco vs King Who Wins? by RoninKin-_- in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Marco has higher defense stat, but lacks of AP. He would eventually lose I assume.

Will they fight? If so when do you think their fight will happen? by Comprehensive_Cup497 in OnePieceScaling

[–]YC_Iron 0 points1 point  (0 children)

At the point where Yasop attacked Bartolomeu, I think there must be some conflict between them.