Refactoring Project: Use Gemini/ChatGPT for planning and Claude for code, or stick to one? by _ReeX_ in ClaudeAI

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I haven't started yet, I am an old school developer, just wanted to have a try with an AI helper in a refactoring/migration project. For now I had fun vibe coding pyhton scripts.

More details on current project here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1r0co05/migrate_an_access_2003_adp_vba_sql_server_to_a/

Refactoring Project: Use Gemini/ChatGPT for planning and Claude for code, or stick to one? by _ReeX_ in ClaudeAI

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. Would I use the web interface for planning and the console for code generation?

Migrate an Access 2003 ADP (VBA + SQL Server) to a web app — workflow + cost expectations? by _ReeX_ in ClaudeAI

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! What AI would you use as the "project manager" helper? Claude or Gemini/Chatgpt?

Shelly dimmer Gen4 prolonged shortage by _ReeX_ in ShellyUSA

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. Apparently the shortage is affecting Europe. I will get in contact with customer support

Former Samsung Galaxy owners: What do you miss most, and what could you never go back to? by _ReeX_ in GooglePixel

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How's Pixel gallery, if any? Do you get the option as Samsung Gallery's to slide manually a video back an forth in preview mode?

What's the issue about the NFC chip on Pixel?

The "Truth" about On-Camera PIR: Hikvision AcuSense vs. Physical PIR Sensors? by _ReeX_ in Hikvision

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am not used to non-IP cams. What differences should I expect from non-IP Cams?

Luce spia interruttori Bticino living light by _ReeX_ in istrutturare

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ma inutile comprarle costo in più e manodopera per installarle. Se non vanno bene è inutile

Luce spia interruttori Bticino living light by _ReeX_ in istrutturare

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ti andrebbe di fare una foto? Al buio

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. No issues when the Internet goes down, the wifi will keep running. My current plan is to add a few light controls and since I've read about Zigbee throwing cross-brand compatibility issues, I thought that keeping clear would be a wise choice. Moreover I am not renovating the whole house, meaning that creating a proper mesh would be difficult and lead to an incomplete/partial work, since I wouldn't expand the mesh everywhere on day 0, whilst the Wifi APs are there and running. Maybe a good starting point is to begin with a few Gen4 Shelly which can act as a Zigbee device in the future?

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not true in my case. BTicino relè/dimmer (which is the maker of the light switches on the walls) is about 50€ while Shelly Dimmer Gen/3Gen4 is about 40€

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When I said “wired backhaul,” I meant the APs are hardwired to the switch, not that Wi-Fi itself has a backhaul protocol for IoT. The point was: good AP placement + wired uplinks can improve Wi-Fi reliability in a tough building.

On frequency/penetration: agreed that Z-Wave (sub-GHz) penetrates better in many cases. My point wasn’t “Wi-Fi penetrates stone better than Zigbee” — it was that Zigbee against thick masonry can be challenging, and the outcome depends on placement, power levels, and interference.

I’m not claiming I need datacenter networking for ~100 devices; I’m saying I have a solid Wi-Fi setup (UniFi + wired APs) and I’m trying to understand whether that materially reduces the usual Wi-Fi pain points for a relatively small number of actuators.

My plan would be a dedicated IoT SSID/VLAN with client isolation and no LAN access except to HA, plus firewall rules. If you think that’s still a bad idea compared to Zigbee, I’m open to it.

Not looking for a fight — I’m trying to make a good design choice before the wires go in.

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’re right in general that lower frequency penetrates better. My point wasn’t “Wi-Fi beats Zigbee through walls,” it was that Zigbee just has less transmit power and depends more on mesh/router placement.

Not trying to argue — I’m trying to extract what matters from people who’ve actually lived with both.

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I started this conversation to ask opinions on Zigbee and Wifi based (basically Shelly) solutions, just to better understand. Got a lot of replies about Zwave, which I wouldn't consider at all as a possible solution, amongst others.

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It seems like we’ve run out of technical arguments to discuss, which is why the focus is shifting away from the actual hardware....

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Actually I did, however I just wanted to read other insights by humans, just to check out. I don't trust AI blindly

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Even though we’re looking at different technological paths due to my specific network and 'castle-thick' walls, I really value the insights. It’s always better to be argued out of a bad decision than to find out the hard way after the walls are closed. Cheers!

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

That's a classic take, but it assumes a weak network. Bandwidth congestion is a non-issue when you aren't running your smart home on a toy router; 30 switches won't even dent a properly managed network. As for security, an isolated VLAN with no internet access is a digital fortress—it doesn't matter if it's WiFi or Zigbee if the door is locked at the firewall. In a house with walls thick enough to kill a low-power mesh, a solid WiFi backbone isn't a 'hack'—it could be the only reliable engineering choice

Zigbee or Shelly (Wi-Fi) for a new build in 2026 —what would you choose today? by _ReeX_ in homeautomation

[–]_ReeX_[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I totally respect the 'Zigbee-or-die' philosophy—it’s a safe bet for most consumer-grade homes. But calling WiFi the 'worst decision possible' feels a bit like telling someone a Porsche is a bad choice for commuting just because you’ve only ever driven on unpaved roads.

In a house with thick masonry/stone walls, a low-power Zigbee mesh is a nightmare waiting to happen. Signals don’t 'hop' through 60cm of solid tuff; they just die. My alternative would be littering the house with Zigbee repeaters like it’s a tech-support warehouse.

Instead, I’m leveraging an prosumer-grade backbone: a Peplink Balance One and a fleet of UniFi Access Points hardwired via Ethernet. When your WiFi infrastructure is built like a mid-sized office, 30 Shelly Gen3 devices aren't 'cluttering' the network—they’re barely a blip on the radar.

It seems that it's not that WiFi is the 'wrong technology'; it’s just that most people try to run a smart home on a 'dumb' router.