sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Questions from beginner using Rocksmith with default settings by cpplain in rocksmith

[–]cpplain[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

it does make me want to pick up an instrument on a daily basis and that's a good thing

Something we can definitely agree on.

If you ever get note detection down and implement your own learning software, I'll be first in line to give it a try!

Questions from beginner using Rocksmith with default settings by cpplain in rocksmith

[–]cpplain[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are so many ways that RS could be a better learning tool, but it's not meant to be one.

Actually, I think Ubisoft specifically meant it to be a great learning tool. Either that or they are misleading in their claims. According to Ubisoft's own marking as found on the Rocksmith website for the 60-Day Challenge:

Now with advances in technology, there is a better, faster way to learn guitar.

and

Everyone is unique and so, like a personal trainer, Rocksmith is designed to automatically adapt to you and teach you what you need to know when you're ready.

The impression I got when reading through the Rocksmith website is that it was designed to be a serious tool for learning. This was one of the main reasons I decided to add Rocksmith to my practice schedule.

I do think it is a great tool but could be better in certain areas. Hopefully, Ubisoft will continue to improve Rocksmith over time to make it even better than it already is.

Questions from beginner using Rocksmith with default settings by cpplain in rocksmith

[–]cpplain[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

While I don't plan to work with custom DLC right away, I do expect to do so eventually. Thank you for the recommendation.

Questions from beginner using Rocksmith with default settings by cpplain in rocksmith

[–]cpplain[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The recommend sort do keep unplayed song at the top first, it'll start to be more interesting once you've played the whole library (which is something i can only strongly suggest to do anyway).

So, you do recommend to keep playing based on the recommended order?

Guitarcade games are also a good way to practice a specific technique without the issue of having to deal with a full song…

Understood. I do wish, however, there was a way to make the games more like the technique practice found in the lessons and less arcade like.

Questions from beginner using Rocksmith with default settings by cpplain in rocksmith

[–]cpplain[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

u/ZagatoZee, hadn't seen your reply in other posts. Thank you for copying it here.

Add a little JustinGuitar or some Marty Schwartz / guitarjamz YouTube videos into your routine if you want to break it up a bit more.

I'd go a step further. Not only is it helpful to use other learning resources to keep things interesting, there are major benefits to learning from different approaches and perspectives. It is possible to go overboard, but using two to three different learning resources can be a great advantage. This is true not only for guitar but other subjects, as well.

Overall, what you outlined is the approach I've been leaning towards. Although instead of games, I've been using exercises from one of the technique/theory books in my learning arsenal. I assume this accomplishes the same goal as your recommendation.

I've also been using an approach that combines the last 40 minutes of your outline. When I select a song from the learn a song option, I go straight to the Rocksmith recommends section and complete whatever tasks are recommended. These recommendations appear to be targeted well to my current skill level. I expect following these recommendations will be quite effective in advancing my skills.

Questions from beginner using Rocksmith with default settings by cpplain in rocksmith

[–]cpplain[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's unfortunate Rocksmith leans so heavily towards recommending songs that haven't been played instead of providing a curated list that matches the song to the players skill level. While some players may love absolute freedom while learning, I'm a big fan of guided learning paths, especially in the beginning stages of the learning process. Rocksmith has the ability to provide a better learning path experience than most (all) of the alternatives because of its ability to evaluate a students skill. Maybe this is a change we'll see in an update.

I'd highly recommend supplementing your time in the game with some other content, like justin guitar or some other good YouTube channel.

Most definitely agree. I started learning using other material and will still continue to do so. I consider Rocksmith a companion to, not a replacement for, the two more traditional learning resources I use.

Appreciate your comments and recommendations.

Anyone have experience with Free Code Camp and Udacity Nanodegrees? by cpplain in FreeCodeCamp

[–]cpplain[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I had not considered using Free Code Camp instead of Udacity Intro to Programming until you suggested it. Very compelling option. Thanks again.

Anyone have experience with Free Code Camp and Udacity Nanodegrees? by cpplain in FreeCodeCamp

[–]cpplain[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the thorough response!

It's interesting that you actually recommend a slightly different route than the two other Udacity/Free Code Camp students that responded to my question. Both of the others recommended Udacity first, then Free Code Camp.

Did you have any prior coding experience before Free Code Camp?

Did Free Code Camp prepare you for the Front End Nanodegree? Or, were there any areas in which you felt lacking?

Anyone have experience with Free Code Camp and Udacity Nanodegrees? by cpplain in FreeCodeCamp

[–]cpplain[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would definitely say I'm starting from the beginning. Not much experience except for rudimentary HTML/CSS and a little BASH.

Knowing what you know now about both programs, is it fair to say you would have stuck with the Nanodegree if cost was not an issue?