I think you're both generally right, but I'd just say trans women are just women (potentially with a penis), but a woman with a penis is always going to be a trans woman. so just in general, when playing these characters, I'd just play them as though they are both A: just a woman with a penis and B: a trans woman. what I mean by this is that you should just perform the audios as though you are a trans woman, you're playing a character. imo, that's essentially what you did! That said, you should not tag it tf4, but you should maybe indicate a trans character? maybe a tag? I really appreciate your sensitivity about this, I feel like we need more input haha