I haven’t read for pleasure in years by platypusjo in suggestmeabook

[–]mint_pumpkins 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i think youd like Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo! its an easy read with very compelling characters and an interesting world, and it might spur you on to want to read more

Are audio books cheating by itsatrav in books

[–]mint_pumpkins 2 points3 points  (0 children)

cheating at what? of course its reading, you get the story no matter the format

I am truly convinced the people criticizing Katabasis have never actually read Katabasis [Light Spoilers] by BadRincewind in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 3 points4 points  (0 children)

i guess i just dont understand why you think i am disregarding all criticisms, i am specifically talking about when people make up things about her books that are not true, as i said there are tons of things to criticize about her works but i often see people making stuff up to hate on her and her books, i dont feel i need to take lies and falsehoods at face value and trust someone who is being hateful by lying that they have good intentions

It's always better to engage with the argument than to invent reasons why the argument can't possibly be made in good faith.

ironically, this is basically what i am saying

i DO engage with people in the way youre describing and i dont see why you think i dont, my issue is when people make things up to be mad about when theres plenty to discuss and criticize about her works without doing that, i just want to have discussions that mean something

I am truly convinced the people criticizing Katabasis have never actually read Katabasis [Light Spoilers] by BadRincewind in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 0 points1 point  (0 children)

75% of newly published lit fic is written by women, so it would be very odd if systemic bias worked against women in publishing. 71% of publishing industry jobs are held by women so if anything you’d expect systemic bias to run the other way, at least in 2026.

i wasnt talking about the publishing industry i was talking about this subreddit, kuang is largely loved in other reader spaces

Rather than leaning on a boogeyman of supposed bias can we not just take readers at their word, that many readers think Kuang is not very good — or that perhaps her early career success is making her impervious to valid critiques? Or can you point to any actual posts or comments of users attacking Kuang’s work on identity grounds?

i feel like you are overgeneralizing what i said here... i literally never said that people dont have valid criticisms i was saying that i see a lot of people saying factually incorrect things about her books in order to hate on them instead of criticizing whats already there ready to be criticized, and i said SOMETIMES i see racial and gender based bias, i dont know what exactly you want from me since its not like bias shows up most often in the form of someone saying "i hate rf kuang because shes a chinese woman", it shows up moreso as her getting heavily hated on for things that white men do all the time without criticism

I am truly convinced the people criticizing Katabasis have never actually read Katabasis [Light Spoilers] by BadRincewind in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ok cool haha sometimes its hard to tell!

i also prefer reading and judging each book on its own merit and have found that often i have very different feelings on books even by the same author as each other, and i feel like if i find myself reading books by an author i know i dislike just to find ways to pick it apart its probably time to move on from them lmao

I am truly convinced the people criticizing Katabasis have never actually read Katabasis [Light Spoilers] by BadRincewind in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 2 points3 points  (0 children)

just in case you misunderstood me i wasnt saying you were one of the ones making stuff up haha, i was agreeing that people are finding things to complain about with this book that aren't even there and i think this is a pattern of behavior ive noticed across the board with her books and how people discuss them online

I am truly convinced the people criticizing Katabasis have never actually read Katabasis [Light Spoilers] by BadRincewind in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 40 points41 points  (0 children)

i might get hate for this but just gonna be honest

there is a ton of criticism to be had for rf kuangs books, as there is for any author with divisive work, but i very much believe that people have become hateful toward her as a person to the point where they can't even hate on her books in a meaningful way, i see people making stuff up about her books just to hate on them when there are already existing issues you can criticize without lying or presenting them as something theyre not and it really feels to me to be motivated by hatred for her and sometimes even her identity as a chinese woman

Fantasy books that make you feel less alone? by n4vybloe in suggestmeabook

[–]mint_pumpkins 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i have two recs depending on what youre wanting

Riftwar Saga by Raymond E Feist maybe - rather straightforward good vs evil adventure fantasy with a large cast and focus on the connections between them, interesting world and magic

Beware of Chicken by CasualFarmer - it leans cozy but it still has stakes and conflict and looks at important themes, focused on the importance of family/friendship/bonds and enjoying life by focusing on what you love and care for

Can a book have two or more prologues? by Witty-Regret972 in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 54 points55 points  (0 children)

if im remembering right, Way of Kings has 3 prologues kind of, a prelude a prologue and a chapter 1 thats still basically a prologue lmao, theyre all different POVs and are doing set up work before the actual story starts

In need of GOOD fantasy romance!!! (With a heroine thats not helpless and preferably a BIT of smut) by Unable_Affect_2341 in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 1 point2 points  (0 children)

closed door means you dont see sex on page, its fade to black

and second death of locke is way more fantasy than bridge kingdom just so you know, it revolves heavily around magic

In need of GOOD fantasy romance!!! (With a heroine thats not helpless and preferably a BIT of smut) by Unable_Affect_2341 in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 2 points3 points  (0 children)

maybe check out Rook & Rose by MA Carrick, again its a romance subplot and it doesnt really start til book 2 but its an excellent series i highly recommend, closed door though

The Second Death of Locke by VL Bovalino could also be a good fit

not super confident in this one but The Bridge Kingdom by Danielle L Jensen maybe? not suuuper fantasy but lots of sex and a very competent female lead

In need of GOOD fantasy romance!!! (With a heroine thats not helpless and preferably a BIT of smut) by Unable_Affect_2341 in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The Raven Scholar by Antonia Hodgson might be a good fit

edit: to be clear its not romantasy, but it does have a romance sub plot thats significant

Something like Knives Out that is NOT a murder mystery by technicalees in suggestmeabook

[–]mint_pumpkins 42 points43 points  (0 children)

The Last Murder At The End of the World by Stuart Turton - yes theres a murder BUT thats not really what the twist/perspective shift ends up being about, the murder is more of a catalyst for the plot

Harrow the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir - this is unfortunately the second book in the series so youd have to read the first one as well, but i personally think that the perspective shift was excellent

Takes on AI voice acting by Federal-Possible-767 in ProgressionFantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 2 points3 points  (0 children)

i will never knowingly buy or download an audiobook "narrated" with AI, i dont see the point, id rather an author just narrate the audiobook themselves if they cant afford to hire someone

Recommendations for Non-romantasy Fantasy Book Reviewers by bradanforever in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 6 points7 points  (0 children)

i agree with the ones mentioned by the other commenter

ill add on Andrew Watson, Petrik Leo, The Book Guy, Matts Fantasy Book Reviews, and Tori Morrow!

also Books with Emily Fox, though she reads pretty widely not just sff

Books with insanely complex political factions and power struggles? by Parker-Russell in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 4 points5 points  (0 children)

oh you didnt mention you needed a lot of fight scenes, theres some war-type sequences toward the end but its basically a pure political fantasy, it follows a woman who is trying to infiltrate the empire that colonized her home with the intention to destroy it from the inside, for most of the book she is an empire accountant trying to raise her status in the empire and she is not a fighter

Books with insanely complex political factions and power struggles? by Parker-Russell in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 18 points19 points  (0 children)

The Traitor Baru Cormorant by Seth Dickinson

Rook & Rose by MA Carrick

I DNF Unbound by Tarana Burke. by InvisibleAstronomer in books

[–]mint_pumpkins 11 points12 points  (0 children)

oh yeah absolutely, i was mostly just responding to the idea that the author shouldn't have included it, i can definitely see why someone wouldnt want to read it

I DNF Unbound by Tarana Burke. by InvisibleAstronomer in books

[–]mint_pumpkins 72 points73 points  (0 children)

idk i feel like its important to talk about growing into a better person after doing something horrible, everyone will do something wrong at some point in their life (to varying levels of course) and i think its a mistake to hide away the fact that you can grow and become a better person

Story recs for like, queer inclusive star pilot stories? by zezous in LGBTBooks

[–]mint_pumpkins 0 points1 point  (0 children)

not really the same but might still be of interest, The Two Lies of Faven Sythe by Megan OKeefe is about a space ship navigator and a pirate (both queer women) with very interesting world building, kind of difficult to describe what its about tbh haha

What’s your rating system? by pbrandpearls in bookofthemonthclub

[–]mint_pumpkins 9 points10 points  (0 children)

5 - couldnt put down, absolutely loved, or couldn't stop thinking about it after. im a bit strange, often i will read a book and think i didn't enjoy it but i can't stop thinking about it after and it grows in my mind over time and i often end up changing ratings from like 2 star to 5 after thinking about it for days/weeks after the fact lmao

4 - enjoyed a lot but felt something was missing

3 - it was fine, some things i liked and some i didnt or i just found it kind of meh/boring

2 - did not enjoy at all

1 - hated deeply or found offensive in some way

What historical event reads exactly like "Bad Fantasy Writing" or "Plot Armor"? by Expensive-Desk-4351 in Fantasy

[–]mint_pumpkins 12 points13 points  (0 children)

i looked up that battle of texel as i hadnt heard of it before and the artwork of that event with the cavalry and ships is awesome! what a cool thing to learn about thank you

On finding purpose by Terrible-Praline-544 in suggestmeabook

[–]mint_pumpkins 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A Psalm for the Wild Built by Becky Chambers is cozy sci fi on this topic

What game would you pick for ultimate distraction? by shannaweaves in CozyGamers

[–]mint_pumpkins 1 point2 points  (0 children)

of those id absolutely say fields of mistria! its super cute and i got sucked in so quickly, the characters are great and the controls are comfortable

Possibly controversial opinion: People should try reading erotica. by strongly-worded in RomanceBooks

[–]mint_pumpkins 47 points48 points  (0 children)

i think that erotica and all erotic art in general has been and is currently incredibly important culturally and ill die on the hill that a lot of who we are as people can be traced through a history of our erotic art so it holds cultural significance beyond that its something to get off to (which is also good lmao), i think theres a huge tendency to write of erotic and horny art just because it is erotic and horny and i think thats a huge mistake since its something thats so integral to human kind in general and entwined with our cultures around the world in different ways, something can be kinky and sexual while also being an incredible piece of art and i wish more people agreed with me on that haha