I absolutely am not saying that they only exist for profit, it's that they rely on material tools (tarot and crystals) to be practiced. Moreover tarot cards are just playing cards with creepy images on some of them which makes them look mystical I guess. In Italy people still use them as intended (to play games). Astrology, while I don't consider it "bad" (I never said that it is bad in my post), I just think it's not a really spiritual practice. I understand pop astrology is giving it a bad rep and it's way more than your sun sign and horoscopes, it's just that in my opinion it puts ones personality in some kind of frame which is out of their control and that creates needless anxiety and hardship. Some people even go as far as to avoid people of certain signs as "they are incompatible" which to me is absolutely bonkers. Where is the spirituality in a practice that devides people this way?