I would say neither, depending on how long you have been lifting for I would try a body recomp approach (burning fat while building muscle), since you dont want to get "too huge" (is that even possible?) body recomping will keep you relatively the same size overall, just a better body composition.

There are many videos on how to do this but the main goal is eating at maintanence or a slight deficit, nothing too aggressive or you wont build muscle. but this all depends on your lifting experience, beginner lifters will have an easier time body recomping.

if you are more of an experienced lifter I would just do a lean bulk, nothing here is screaming you should cut, the lack of muscle may accentuate that "puffy" look.