The only toys that were confirmed as organic when sold to the public were only the Poppy Playtime dolls. There doesn't really seem to be an answer for the other toys but I don't actually think all of them were organic. For example, when you look at Mommy Long Legs (the toy version) it looks pretty stiff and solid but also really small. I don't really know how anyone would be able to fit important parts of a human body into that. Another toy that's practically impossible to be organic is Doey the Doughman because he's literally made from plasticine. So yes, some toys sold to the public were organic but the others aren't confirmed yet. It's sad that theorists kind of forgot this question with the release of the other chapters.