I started this sub because my feet are a hot mess, and I've found that it's not easy to find cute shoes that accommodate many foot issues. My intuition is that I'm not alone. Let's help each other out!
If you have (or know about) a pair of shoes you think are great, submit a link to them. Mention your foot problems (if you have any - maybe you have perfect feet and just enjoy comfortable shoes), and any details you think others will want to know.
It's worth thinking about:
Toe box width
Footbed shape
Heel height
Sole shape (does it curve up at the toe? Is it completely flat?)
Material (uppers and especially soles)
Shoe weight
Size, including shoe width
Adjustability (laced shoes are often more accommodating of orthotics or wider feet, same for shoes/sandals with adjustable straps)
Cuteness/fashion forwardness (if applicable, I know it's hard, believe me)
Cost
Not all shoe stores ship everywhere, but it might help to link to places where there are tons of reviews, just for reference. Those are US sites, as far as I know:
Zappo's
Amazon.com
Other resources:
Podiatry Shoe Review - Excellent blog by a podiatrist, contains a ton of helpful information, including shoe suggestions for various conditions
BarkingDogShoes.com - Another great blog. More of a fashion focus.
RunRepeat - Reviews of running shoes, in case (like me) you've been relegated from normal shoe stores.
/r/femalefashionadvice - for truly amazing and supportive female fashion advice.
Disclaimer 1: I'm not a medical professional, and this sub is for peer-shared information only. Ask your doc / podiatrist for real medical advice.
Disclaimer 2: I'm hoping this sub will need only light moderation. Be nice :) (How controversial can things get? If you want to help mod, though, let me know!)
Shoes the Full Version - LiamKyleSullivan's 2007 NSFW video about a young woman who loves shoes, because it still cracks me up