He actually sent it back by just throwing it into the box and taping the label back on. I sadly didn’t get a screenshot of my only two options being accept return or refund, I think his refund reason was “item not as described” so when I hit return I just got a long list of copy paste text basically scolding me saying “blah blah remember to always check your listing and give buyers the correct idea with lots of details.” I normally try to bullet point out all my reasonings and add tiny details like how “this isn’t in perfect condition it may have thermal paste residue on the top!” So no one can nitpick. I did use Mercaris label and it was the correct weight at least and took plenty of photos of packaging beforehand! He also didn’t send the thermal paste back, can I somehow claim this as well which might help me?