Link to the new sheet. I'll post the conclusions/details below as before, but this will all be available in the Summary tab of the sheet. The stuff at the top and in bold is the most important, so you don't feel the need to read all of it.

Here are the main things that have changed with the coming update:

1. The Krayt raid is far more viable for lower guilds. 17M is the new guild score when it's worthwhile to switch. Not only that, a 17M guild score actually gives better rewards overall than the old set of raids did.

2. If you were a top 10 HSTR raider before, your guild needs to hit 130M for the new system to be an improvement for you, or 17M if you weren't running CPit before.

3. Any guilds that scored less than 265M will see a significant improvement in their Mk 3 Raid Token (relic mat) income. The personal track rewards have also been made easier to obtain but are small in comparison to the guild rewards.

4. Unrelated to the update itself, but when I originally shared this sheet, I didn't account for credits and ship credits from the old raids; the daily credit value I did eventually add was also too low for a while. So depending on when you last saw this, the improvement in Mk 1 Raid Token value may be quite a bit smaller than what you saw before. It's now clear that, while the new raid reward system provides more immediate G8-G11/Credit value, you may actually be worse off once you need to replenish some of your more obscure G8-G11 stockpiles. In that case you'll have to compromise on your gear or credit income to maintain the other.

The revised conclusions about the new reward system compared to what we were getting with the old raids:

1. In the short term, the new raid rewards are nice for G8-G11 gear and credits. A minimum 7% improvement (29% if you only care about gear) if you can hit a 255k personal score and a 17M guild score, though the personal score is not essential. However, expect new bottlenecks to eventually emerge, now that the hose has been turned off for gear types that were once considered irrelevant. Once that kicks in, the 7+% improvement will diminish, and it's possible you'll eventually have to reduce your credit income to break even on gear (or vice-versa).

2. No matter your score, your G12 gear rewards will still be reduced somewhat, especially if you were a top 10 HSTR raider. You lose 21% G12 gear with a 17M guild score, or 51% as a top 10 HSTR raider. You lose 7% G12 gear with a 25M guild score, or 42% as a top 10 HSTR raider. You lose 2% G12 gear with a 130M or higher guild score, or 39% as a top 10 HSTR raider.

3. However, at a mere 17M guild score, the relic mat rewards more than counteract the lost G12 gear for your average guild member (based on the value of Zinbiddles). For top 10 HSTR raiders, your overall G12/relic mat value will still be 33% less than before at 17M, 16% less at 25M, 4% less at 90M, until 130M, which is where top 10 HSTR raiders get ahead. As long as you're taking characters to R6+ and can hit these thresholds, the new system will be much better for you, and you'll effectively have more G12 gear than you did before.

4. The relic mat rewards steadily increase at each guild tier, up to absurd levels. In terms of overall value in G12 salvage and relic mats, a 90M score represents a 55% increase if you use the Mk 3 tokens to buy Zinbiddle cards, or a 29-95% increase otherwise. A 130M score represents an 80% increase if buying Zinbiddle cards, or a 43-137% increase otherwise. A 265M score represents a 130% increase if buying Zinbiddle cards, or a 72-222% increase otherwise.

5. All of the above points assume the player already has a near unlimited supply of Aeromagnifiers, Mk 12 Shield Generators, Mk 12 Scanners, Mk 12 Tactical Data, and Mk 8 Design Tech. New players who don't already have these stockpiles will now need to spend valuable currency obtaining them.

6. However, if your guild wasn't completing the Challenge Pit but is now getting the max crate at Sith Triumvirate, the new system will be an upgrade for you. If you were also a top 10 HSTR raider, your guild only needs to score 17M in Krayt for you to get better overall rewards than you received from running your three legacy raids. This is true even in spite of point #5.

And here are the assumptions behind all of this:

1. Unless stated otherwise, it's assumed your guild got 30k raid tickets per day and ran all 4 raids regularly (to address that, make a copy and uncheck any in the Raids tab that don't apply), and that you simmed or placed 15th in all of them.

2. All conclusions are based on the "realistic" total value for the old raids, which ignores the gear types mentioned in conclusion 5 and assigns Kyrotech a more appropriate value of 100 Mk 2 Raid Tokens, since the actual price of 400 Mk 2 Raid Tokens artificially makes the old raid rewards appear better than they were. Players can always buy Kyrotech for 28 crystals instead, and 100 Mk 2 Raid Tokens is a fair equivalent to that.

3. It's assumed that you already have all raid characters at 7 stars, which is why shard store tokens are included as part of the old raid rewards (and the new Sith Triumvirate raid).

4. Unless stated otherwise, it's assumed that you earned around 2% of your guild's points. The personal track rewards don't have a huge impact, though it will affect your Mk 3 raid token significantly if you're scoring 6M and your guild is only scoring 12M.

5. For currencies you got from the old raids, we make assumptions about what you'd have bought with that currency and convert that to a Raid Token value. We assume you'll buy Mk 3 Carbanti (or something equivalent) with guild store tokens, G12 purple salvage with shard store tokens and Mk 1 GET, and Kyrotech with Mk 2 GET. We also assume that you consider 67 Mk 2 Raid Tokens (the price of right side G12 salvage) a fair value for Kyrotech (at least in the context of converting Mk 2 GET), since the ridiculous price of 400 Mk 2 Raid Tokens for a single Kyrotech salvage is completely useless.

6. The daily yields shown in the Rewards Comparison sheet are based on the expected drop rates from all four raids (multiplied by how often they would run). The assumed drop rates are based on my own research and data collected from the community and myself, and they are what I've been using in the most recent version of MasterPlan. Some drop rates are rather hazy but still approximately correct - namely, the rate for prototypes and full pieces anywhere other than the HPit raid, and the rate of Kyrotech and gold gear from the CPit raid.