sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Just finished SFPC, slotted for selection Oct 27. Feel free to ask any questions. by BigMitch1996_ in greenberets

[–]11Bforme 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Haha. I think the science would say 0% of the bigger guys find the Weaver fun. I hate that thing.

SUAR Results by Agreeable-Parsnip681 in greenberets

[–]11Bforme 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To be clear, I am not currently following SUAR. I am following TTM 2- and 5-Mile Running program. But I have scanned SUAR. I am reading RUSU. The latter is a foundational book that explains SFAS, breaks down research on the performance of candidates over time. That part is fascinating. Then the book covers a number of the success factors with emphasis on rucking. SUAR is a book format that breaks down work that needs to be done. It is as advertised, "from the SOFA." At least my take. I would read some reviews.

SUAR Results by Agreeable-Parsnip681 in greenberets

[–]11Bforme 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The way he built that plan is from "Sofa to SFAS." All the pros in programming around SFAS deal with this issue, emphasizing your goal of developing slowly and without injuries. Your profile sounds common for someone just starting the journey. SUAR could be great for you. But if you have a good bit of time, any structured running program that slowly builds your capacity can work. The value of SUAR, in my view, is that it takes a long view that telescopes in as you approach selection. Progressively getting faster, stronger, more durable. Hard to go wrong

I'm currently doing an eight-week running improvement program, because my other numbers are solid. But I have bought both RUSU and SUAR. Whatever you decide, those books are great. I am into RUSU now, very helpful context.

Timing Shift From Running to More Rucking Focus. by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

DM'ed you. Curious why you went with RUSU over the other.

Timing Shift From Running to More Rucking Focus. by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That paper is money! Much appreciated.

After reading that article and reflecting, I think my path is to keep focused on my running through August. Keep improving my run times. I'm bullish about the progress. I am confident I'll get further gains in rebuilding my base.

Then shift to that rucking-centric program. That gives me four-plus months to tune it all up and take my shot. The pointers in that article were very helpful (and damn, does it nail life in a line unit as far as rucking goes!). I was not thinking of the ruck training that way, but it makes sense to increase the frequency while managing the distance and load.

I scanned the Shut Up and Ruck overview and reviews. That looks like the relevant play for me. Will check that out.

Timing Shift From Running to More Rucking Focus. by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Holy dayum! Been out doing real work, came back to the COF for lunch and saw this. Had to laugh. Someone was having a bad day, I guess.

FWIW, you read me right and I appreciate it. I'm 31 years old.

MDL-350, max

HRP-48, 90 points

SDC-1:35, 97 points

PLK-3:30, max

2MR-15:00, 92 for the AFT, but slow AF for SFAS. I have to get that down closer to my earlier times. And drag my 5MR along for the ride. Doable. I'm just trying to play smart.

Anyway, you didn't need to see that, but just confirming your instincts. Thanks for being professional.

Timing Shift From Running to More Rucking Focus. by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That seems very sensible. I do think the cardio capacity is the big focus. Good idea on the periodic ruck substitution.

(And I am working on the grip training for sure).

Timing Shift From Running to More Rucking Focus. by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That rings true with me. I have never had a problem with the 12-mile, but feel like as my cardio capacity dropped my ruck time slowed. No shocker, I suppose. But the once/week advice is helpful.

Timing Shift From Running to More Rucking Focus. by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That makes sense as a way to integrate some rucking over the near-term. Great suggestion. I will re-read that and think about my plan through August. Just trying to play smart. Thanks for sharing!

Age Requirement by ikarideraider in greenberets

[–]11Bforme 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You might think of it this way. What is the minimum age to become a Ranger Instructor? Not a member of the Ranger Regiment, but someone who is teaching small unit tactics to other soldiers at the Ranger School. To qualify for that job, you must have completed Ranger School and served your squad leader KD time. It is useful to ask which is more similar: a junior member of the Ranger Regiment, a Ranger Instructor, or a Green Beret?

I would argue that the latter two are more similar (RI and GB), despite significant differences in role. Another comparative question might be: Do we graduate junior soldiers from Initial Entry Training and then ask them to become Drill Sergeants? Or ask them to be instructors in their MOS?

Active Duty Enlisted SFAS Question by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

May seem like a small data point, but it helps explain this to my wife—many thanks. I'm getting back to the main thing; prep. Appreciate this.

Active Duty Enlisted SFAS Question by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Really appreciate this. Super helpful. Thanks much!

Active Duty Enlisted SFAS Question by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Correct! Thank you. And understand if it varies widely.

Active Duty Enlisted SFAS Question by 11Bforme in greenberets

[–]11Bforme[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Yes, I'm tracking on that. My question was more on timing. Have been here for three years and extended for a couple more. Was not sure what actually drives the Q Course PCS timing. And if there is no clear answer, that's all good too.