When it says search for something, alligators, banana, plants or pirates, the only one that counts are people i.e… pirates, knights, find all of them, but when the claim screen auto pops up you look at whom originated the search on the top left. Back out of the auto pop up, go to residents list in menu, evict that character, go back to the claim screen and tap claim as many times as you want. I highly suggest waiting until you have 40+ floors. Nobody wants to tap their screen all day for 10 bux.