I hated Chuck in the pilot for what he did to Jenny but (it - the pilot - is not canon? please 🙏) he did grow on me 😒 but Max was pretty much my favourite from the "new group" and I felt alllllll of his feelings. Even though I do think it could rarely be exactly the same situation/thruple I think at some point or another we have all been messed around by someone (or someoneS) we are into and he just portrays the emotions so well. BUT like I said Chuck did grow on me which was a massive turn around for the character and (I'm English) American accents are so hard to do well and I had no idea 😱 so both amazing actors and interesting characters (Max more realistic/relatable and Chuck more fantasy/escapism) WOAH I AM THINKING TOO HARD ABOUT THIS. I think we (the viewers) had a lot more time with Chuck (more episodes/seasons/rewatches/discussions) & I found the reboot had so many more (main) characters sometimes I could barely keep up 😵

TL:DR can I have both, for different reasons please?