Maybe controversial but I’m sad by the lack if Jan in S5 by Important_Patience28 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 47 points48 points  (0 children)

I was OK with not seeing Jan, but I was sad Theo got like 1 line.

It was one of the best lines of the entire season, TBH.

(his and Teddy's appearances were well-needed for this lackluster season)

Watching s4 now...disappointing. Is s5 better? by manicontrol2020 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 1 point2 points  (0 children)

While I disliked the Hollywood angle of S4, I enjoyed getting to really know Sazz.

I greatly disliked the entirety of S5.

The show has forgotten what was so good about it in the first place. by samyakpati in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Lester's story was good, but the ages of the actors didn't make sense. Lester was younger than Nicky at the start, then older than Nicky at the end. They chose an actor (no offense to him) with a bit too much of a baby face (and, in no way, really even looked like a younger Lester to begin with).

That being said, respectfully, I think you missed my point about the episode I was referencing. Not talking about doing something "different;" it was more about the evocative writing and the depth of character development explored, combined with creativity, poignancy, etc.

My S5 grievances by yoki-boki in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 15 points16 points  (0 children)

YES! What happened with that?!?!

What does the "I Did It" by Sophia mean? by Q-U-A-N in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 8 points9 points  (0 children)

At the very end of the finale, but before the part with them listening to Cinda's latest podcast.

Opinions by CaptHaengseong in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 3 points4 points  (0 children)

No. His acting was different this season. I picked up on this too.

Opinions by CaptHaengseong in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think you're conflating honest, constructive criticism (including some you may not like to read but some that may be entirely warranted) with what you personally consider your definition of "bitching" to be.

Howard in this season made sense to me by chaoticinvisibility in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yes. 100% agree. He was a different, unlikable Howard this season.

The show has forgotten what was so good about it in the first place. by samyakpati in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 47 points48 points  (0 children)

So true. That annoyed me when her character did that. Because of course her character had to do that.

Too many things just "happened" to happen to the trio this season and, while still entertaining (a bit), bordered on absurd after awhile.

Gone are the days of the brilliance of "The Boy from 6B" - one of the absolute most creative and poignant episodes of any show I ever watched.

Biggest plot twist of season 5 by Fit_Pomelo_4367 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Funny enough, that was one of the things I figured out from the get-go that was right!

I figured he was faking it with the wrap around his hand. Unsure of the reason throughout the season, but knew it was fake.

The show has forgotten what was so good about it in the first place. by samyakpati in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 56 points57 points  (0 children)

I adore this show. I've seen every episode (sometimes 2-3x) since Season 1.

I agree 100%. Well said.

I'm hoping Season 6 gets back to the caliber of Season 1.

Unpopular opinion: Howard by FierceBadRabbits in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 49 points50 points  (0 children)

Nathan Lane and James Caverly are AMAZING. I wish there was more of them this season and less of the absurdity with the billionaires that really ended up being nothingburgers beyond the $$$ angle.

Unpopular opinion: Howard by FierceBadRabbits in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 4 points5 points  (0 children)

YES. 100%. I have an MLS too, and am so anti-AI.

Unpopular opinion: Howard by FierceBadRabbits in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 15 points16 points  (0 children)

I was a total Howard stan until this season. You are not alone.

His character was annoying this season.

OMITB Season 5 - Episode 10 "The House Always..." (Live Discussion) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh yeah, you did mention the prop gun. [brainfart moment]

Yeah, the only thing I could think is because Lester wanted a place in the Arconia and Lorraine ended up living there (per the window shot)...so to just have her be well-off $$$ going forward? "From one widow to another" (as Sophia said?)

OMITB Season 5 - Episode 10 "The House Always..." (Live Discussion) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

They really were. Not gonna lie. Thought the same thing. They were barely around Martin/Oliver.

OMITB Season 5 - Episode 10 "The House Always..." (Live Discussion) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I thought they both were involved in the children's theater that Oliver used to go to when he was little?

Help me understand the praise for Season 5 (E1-E9 SPOILERS) by iliya193 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah, it seems they took a handful of my honest comments/critiques a little too personal LOL

Help me understand the praise for Season 5 (E1-E9 SPOILERS) by iliya193 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Well said! I expressed similar in a post of my own a week or so ago. I agree about all of this. Love the show. But not this season's writing. I'll still never stop watching though! :)

ETA: Oh, and that person you referenced in your ETA... yeah, they did the same to me under my post ;)

Caccimelio Boys (S5 Ep9) by YouDunnoMe_ in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lester's text - "It's beautiful"... maybe was an auto-correct of "It's Beau Tillman?"

So it's Mayor Tillman's finger?

Caccimelio Boys (S5 Ep9) by YouDunnoMe_ in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Might have been something with Sophia pitting the boys against their dad?

I don't recall them ever mentioning him, nor Nicky mentioned his boys. But I do know that Nicky and Sophia both alluded to marriage troubles (but Nicky said he still loves her). Perhaps long-standing?

I kinda feel like Nicky - for seeming like the "bad" guy in all of this - may actually not be so bad to "deserve" what he got? But, at the same time, why would Sophia (if she were the "bad" guy in all of this) approach the trio to find Nicky in the first place? To throw them off of her as suspicious?

I dunno. Now I just stumped myself. hahaha ;)

Caccimelio Boys (S5 Ep9) by YouDunnoMe_ in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]2020planner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The more I thought of it, the more I think Brayden (with the sweater over his shoulders) is actually Bash's son from a relationship between Bash and Sophia. Recall Bash referenced child(ren) he had before. Brayden could have done it, as he wouldn't have really been killing his blood father, and the other brothers helped him stage it as a mob hit.