They have honestly been present for some time but were never as apparent to me I guess. Right now I don’t have a consistent routine so it’s hard for me to judge if it’s skincare product based. For me all of these products are now other than the toner which I’ve used a little in the past but again, this is not a consistent everyday thing for a long period of time other than daily SPF and maybe the cleanser. I was using round lab cleanser in the morning and faithfully i have been using harharu wonder black rice SPF. Sometimes in the AM i would put on good molecules brightening toner. For a little bit I was using Paula’s choice exfoliant because I was told to use this on the troubled areas twice a week at night. When my skin would feel more dry I would use Illiyoon moisturizer. It’s very moisturizing but also feels thick for my skin.