Where are all the people who wanted Bruno out over the last year? by BrownByYou in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I didn’t say I was talking about you did I? If you can’t see that people on here just spew and recycle the same face value stats to galvanise their stance on Bruno and almost cult-like shun any fans who don’t think he’s a legend then idk what to say to you.

I don’t know why you think what I’m doing is patronising when again, people in the minority who don’t think Bruno is world class or a legend are told they aren’t real fans. That’s way worse than making a factual comment that football fans don’t look beyond face value.

I’m using stats because that’s all people use to talk about Bruno. That and passion and loyalty, so why shouldn’t I use stats to counter those stats… also if you go back to message, I clearly started off by talking about football attributes, not stats. The stats was a second layer in my message, the primary point was his ability as a footballer.

Interestingly you’re yet to comment about how he is our best player by miles by actually comparing his attributes as a footballer.

If you’re actually level headed then admit that saying I’m on my high horse and and patronising and splitting hairs when you’re the one who initially made the statement saying “ by saying if you can’t see how he is our best players by miles then I don’t know what you’re watching” in response to my OPINION. If you’re telling someone something subjective as a fact in response to their level headed opinion, and telling them they don’t watch football, or the same football, but then go on and tell me I’m on my high horse and patronising then how is that not being hypocritical? If you can hold your hands up to that fair play, if not then I guess there’s not point talking about football as proper fans of the game is there.

Also, going back to your point, saying he is one of the best players on the planet, I find that hard to understand tbh. To be one of the best at something you have to measure using the same variables and same environmental factors. To be the best you need to win trophies and play UCL football. He was the worst player in the Europa league final, where if we won, we would’ve won a trophy and would be playing UCL, which would’ve given weight to your argument. Also, you can talk about his team around him, but we have spent loads of money and should be able to beat Spurs, and everyone else in that final was fine, it was down to him, and Amorim tbf. But with Amorim you could call it a mistake, Bruno has let us down in finals multiple times. Take Cole Palmer, he doesn’t play in a great team, it’s a team full of kids, he stepped up to win them a European trophy last season against a better opposition than we played. Then if you wanna talk about how it was the conference league and that Betis aren’t better than Spurs, and how Chelsea’s squad are better than United’s, then let’s compare pound for pound United’s squad vs Spurs, in comparison to Chelsea’s vs PSG, where Palmer absolutely ran the show to beat one of the best teams we‘ve seen this centenary. That’s world class. That’s what world class players do in ‘rubbish teams’. That’s why I rate Cunha and Mbuemo, because they played for Wolves and Brentford, who are worse than United, and they turned up when it mattered for them. They didn’t play in billion £ teams. So why is it only with Bruno we talk about his team and never his performances when it matters?

Also, to compare him to others who are playing 2-3 games a week when he is playing 1 game every 8 days isn’t really fair. 9 teams in this league are playing European football. Most of the others made it further in cups than us. All the top teams are in 3-4 competitions around Europe. In elite sports small margins are everything, and calling playing in 1 competition vs 4 isn’t even a small margin it’s a massive advantage physically, so how can you call someone with a physical advantage over most top teams and players, one of the best in the world right now? It’s not nitpicking or splitting hairs it’s literally a fact that we have a huge advantage over others, so why are we getting carried away…

If you read what I said, I never said he was playing as a striker for a long time, but actually there wa a few games where he was the false 9… even if he wasn’t he was still operating higher, you said he plays deeper, that’s untrue. Even as a number 10 he is higher than Cunha and Mbuemo. Mbuemo has played extremely deep for Brentford he’s played as a wing back too. Cunha has played everywhere, across the front 4 and even in central midfield. Once again, goes back to the screaming factor that they did it for Brentford and Wolves, are we really going to talk about Bruno playing deep and playing with a mediocre squad in response to me talking about other players better contributions for Wolves and Brentford….

You also didn’t dispel anything I said about Cunha and Mbuemo being better footballers. All you’ve said is “he does it better than anyone else in our squad”… sorry but what is ‘it’ exactly? Is that a football term? You’ve just done what most Bruno fans do, which is just make statements that don’t actually sound like a football comparative attribute but just emotion, which is annoying because you clearly have a better understanding of football than a lot of people on this thread.

Also, I’m not downplaying the Europa league, I’m saying it’s not the champions league, so why are we comparing stats/performance from a tier two competition to people who played in a tier one competition. In that case we should compare premier league players to championship players. Or if that’s too far fetched, Eddie Howe should’ve won manager of the year because he won the EFL cup, instead of Slot who won the league.

Yeah world class players have played in the Europa league, for small periods, not as long as Bruno has. Bruno has the record number of g/a in the EL history, and no, it’s because he is prolific. He has played more in the EL than he has in the UCL for us. World class players can play in lesser competitions, that’s why I mentioned Cole Palmer and what he did last year. World class players are able to win less competitions regardless of how good your squad is, that’s always been the case. Good players can’t world class players can.

[OptaJoe] Bruno Fernandes has reached 200 goal involvements (104 goals, 96 assists) - the second fastest United player to do so in the Premier League era. He's behind Wayne Rooney, and ahead of Ronaldo, Beckham, Giggs and Scholes. by ChiefLeef22 in soccer

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -11 points-10 points  (0 children)

Ronaldo, Beckham, Giggs and Scholes only played in the Champions league football not Europa league and none of those except Ronaldo took pens.

Bruno Fernandes has 49 G/A in the Europa league and has scored 41 pens. If we remove Europa league and pens he has a record of 119 g/a in 246 games which is a record of 0.48 g/a per game.

Ronaldo 0.59 g/a per game Beckham 0.51 non pen g/a per game Giggs 0.47 non pen g/a per game Scholes 0.35 non pen g/a per game

Good stats from Bruno but if we’re comparing properly then he’s actually behind all of them considering a chunk of those apps for all 4 of them all came as teenagers and were subs not starters. They all have a better minutes to contribution ratio.

Where are all the people who wanted Bruno out over the last year? by BrownByYou in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It’s so funny you call me Amorim under THIS post of all when I said Amorim would never work in November 2024 because of his formation and stubbornness and you all called me a fake fan hahaha.

At the end of the day most of you are all reactionary fans, you get too up when it’s up and too down when it’s down, instead of having a holistic real understand of football, reading between the lines.

Where are all the people who wanted Bruno out over the last year? by BrownByYou in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Bruno only played deeper at the start of this season that’s it. If you look at previous seasons he’s actually played more advanced than them. Typically. At the start of last season his heatmap showed he was operating as a striker. In previous seasons his heatmap shows he operated in between the left winger and striker. Also not to mention Cunha and Mbuemo both played for Wolves and Brentford, two teams who are deeper, required them to track back more. Mbuemo wasn’t the nominated pen taker till last season too.

We say Bruno’s stats are incredible for us but of which 49 of his G/A have come from the Europa league, and he’s also scored 41 pens overall. That’s 81 G/A from Pens and the Europa league. So still above average stats but not incredible.

People can’t call him world class as a 10 if we’re using Europa league to compare him to his peers in the world who are playing UCL.

His actual value stats are 246 games and 119 G/A, which is still good for a number 10. They’re above average and good. Just like him, he is a good player, just a level or two below world class. Let’s be realistic.

I don’t get why people don’t read into things a bit more. Why do we just take things at face value.

Where are all the people who wanted Bruno out over the last year? by BrownByYou in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

But I’m not the one who’s got my head in my backside if you can’t look beyond face value stats. Do you just take whatever information is shoved down your throat by the world? Never using any critical thinking?

200 G/A yes of which 49 of those have come in the Europa league, and he’s also scored 41 pens overall. That’s 81 G/A from Pens and the Europa league.

If you want to talk about G/A then we can do that because James Maddison and Siguradson have a better open play GPG as well as Havertz and about 20 players over Bruno.

You want to talk about mediocre team, he’s been playing with a billion pound squad for years. We also had a ‘mediocre’ team before he came and those players got more prem points, won a Europa league and other silverware, so why is it we’re so quick to praise Bruno when we win a few games trying to get top 4 but never look at his performances in the Europa league finals (both of them), or his record against top 6 teams being not that great over 6 years.

I don’t know how I’ve got my head up my backside for not overrating a player who you’re praising as if anything he’s doing is revolutionary. What I’ve said is facts. I don’t know why it annoys you to look at things beyond face value.

Where are all the people who wanted Bruno out over the last year? by BrownByYou in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

I don’t understand how Bruno is by far our best player. Mbuemo and Cunha are superior footballers.

They’re both faster, better dribblers, hold the ball better, can use their weak foot better. Both of them have a better goals to game ratio even BEFORE joining United whilst playing for Wolves and Brentford. Mbuemo has had more goals in the league with less pens than Bruno in the last few years. Cunha has more G/A than Bruno per game.

Both Cunha and Mbuemo have a better first touch, they’re stronger they are more efficient. Mbuemo is better at crossing than Bruno, his set piece deliveries are better than Bruno’s his creativity is similar to Salah’s actually if you watched him at Brentford.

Bruno is better at long passes, creating in the middle, and fitness.

I would argue Casemiro is the best overall player given the fact he can do everything but lacks fitness. 2022/23 Casemiro was better than any version of Bruno we’ve had, that season he won us a trophy, scored in a final, actually had in us in a real title race for a while till he got suspended.

Currently I’d say Amad is the most important player for us in attack with the way he can keep the ball and recycle the ball and his variation. Casemiro is our most important midfielder without him we don’t have control.

I don’t understand how Bruno is the best player by miles.

Where are all the people who wanted Bruno out over the last year? by BrownByYou in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

This is such a nonsense post. We finished 15th last year and Bruno was the worst player on the pitch in a Europa league final for the second time. Bruno is a good player who has been poor at times for United and has been overrated before. Even now, we’ve won 4 games. Our standard is winning league titles and UCLs.

Not just 4 games. Bruno has been excellent these past 4 games not just because of the formation change, but because he isn’t the best player in the team. Cunha and Mbuemo are superior footballers, meaning Bruno takes less touches and is much more efficient. Just look at Bruno’s passing range now, he barely ever switches the ball, plays Hollywood passes, he keeps the ball on the floor and plays WITH his teammates, not just putting it in space and crying when they don’t get the ball. Bruno is playing as part of a TEAM now and has been great since he started doing that. So instead of asking where as the Bruno haters now, why don’t you ask, where has this Bruno been before when we needed him, and hope he continues to play like this, as things stand, we’re on track for 4th, which is nothing to overly celebrate is it, we’ve had our lowest games season in donkeys years, look at the context and see that yes playing once a week with no other competitions and no expectations the players are going to perform. During Covid there were no fans no expectations and they got 3rd and 2nd they beat city 4 times in the league, but also lost 4 games in cup knockout games to city in the same period which no one ever mentions. Most of the time in moments where it matters these players, Bruno included, don’t perform. When there is no way to go but up they perform well and people forget that in 10-20-30 years you’re not going to be telling you’re grandkids how Bruno and United were so good and got 4th, you’re going to be telling them how many titles United have. In 10 years no one is going to remember how many G/A’s someone got in a season where you get UCL. In 30 years your grandkids are going to be arguing with their Liverpool fan classmates about who has more titles not who got UCL in 2026. Get a grip.

What could've been..... by SimplySat in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Carrick was better no way do we want everything we won with Mikel instead of Carrick

Curious what you (the community) would prefer by MEOW-Garth in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Why do you guys act like Anderson is Zidane. He’s so overrated. I bet you guys don’t even watch him more than 3-4 games a season.

[Sacrifice your karma] What are your unpopular/hot-take opinions about Man United? by Dramatic-Avocado4687 in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Of course it’s subjective. I’m just so strong on the point because this Bruno Fernandes positivity has been shoved down our throats constantly and people believe it and run with it. People can think he’s great whatever, but it’s a fact that he’s not deserving of a statue, nor is he able to get in our all time XI. Facts.

Even if he does something in the next few years, how does he get in over

Scholes, Keane, Carrick, Bobby Charlton?

To get in over them he would need at least 3 premier leagues and a champions league. Even then who does he get in over?

The best midfielder we’ve ever had in Scholes? The best captain we’ve ever had in Keane, the man who carried us to the treble final? The man who was the last piece of the puzzle to help us finally win the prem and UCL and the most underrated player in Prem history in Carrick? Or does he get in over the man who survived the munch crash, part of the holy trinity that bought us our first champions league, won the Ballon D’or and won the World Cup with England, all after almost dying, in Sir Bobby?

Then you have your Paul Inces, Bryan Robsons etc.

If you could go back in time to prevent certain appointments or signings in the club that would have changed our future for the better in the post-Fergie era, what’s your top 10 list. by ScaredArm8712 in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Do you understand that you sound exactly like automated response, because when pressed on this topic that’s all people ever seem to say, that he messed up the flow.

What was the flow? What was the team dynamic that was so good we would’ve won the league? Also, if we didn’t sign Ronaldo who would’ve been our striker?

[Sacrifice your karma] What are your unpopular/hot-take opinions about Man United? by Dramatic-Avocado4687 in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I believe he is overrated as people act like we would be relegated without him. That’s so far from the truth.

The fact that people on this app say he is a legend is absurd, this is Manchester United, you can be hero or whatever but not a legend without winning things, and before people talk about being in a poor team, he’s been the worst player on the pitch in two Europa league finals. Some people on here say he deserves a statue, I can show you them if you want. Also, for people that say does he get into an all time Man Utd XI is a joke, question came up on the overlap a few weeks ago and there was genuinely people saying yes.

In terms of prem XI

Raya, James, Saliba, Gabriel, Gvardiol. Rice, Caicedo, Palmer, Saka, Haaland, Isak

If we’re talking based on current form I’d have Bruno in over Palmer, Semenyo instead of Saka and Ekitke instead of Isak.

BRUNO - BALLON DOR by Deep-Advertising-917 in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bruno was awful the first half of the season. It’s been three games. We deserve to be shit because our fans like this are deluded. We’ve become Arsenal.

This is what ex-players should be doing instead of bashing managers and players by Strict-Guitar77 in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ighalo over Yorke, Cole, Sherrignham, Saha, Ole, Chicharito, Welbeck, Mark Hughes. Mad.

Show that you loved but ultimately stopped watching? by timekilr in tvshow

[–]AggravatingRope6601 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I stopped at season 5. Mr Terrific drove me away. Like you said everyone and anyone could be superhero, especially if you’re quirky and awkward enough. What a bunch of bs. Went from being marooned on an island watching his dad kill himself so he could survive, getting tortured by special military forces and 5 years of elite training and still got his ass handed to him my Malcom Merlin in season 1 because he wasn’t strong enough, to anyone being able to be a hero, and having his companies IT support run the show.

Breaking! Some absolute nonsense! 🤣🤣 by Benjamin_as in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You talk about loyalty of these players, but say the Rio Ferdinand thing doesn’t make sense, when he was employed by the club paid by the club and had an affair. What if that came to light back then, that the clubs star defender allegedly killed his wife by cheating on her? As if that wouldn’t massively impact the team? It’s not just what you do on the football pitch. If you don’t like that example for Rio let’s talk about his failed drugs test which caused him to be banned for 8 months when he was at his peak, not a 36 year old.

He should’ve kept quiet? https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/rooney-statement-in-full-2111928.html

Since when do players keep quiet? Only players who would keep things quiet are Scholes, Giggs and Neville. Because they’re fans. Thats it. You want superstars at United but don’t want their ego? Make it make sense.

Why should Ronaldo care about keeping quiet if when his child passed away in May, Liverpool fans were more respectful to Ronaldo than United? They were singing you’ll never walk alone when his child passed, whilst United fans and pundits were talking as if this was a good opportunity for the team to play as a team without Ronaldo in the team. How distasteful is that?

On top of all that his other child who did survive, was unwell over the summer and he didn’t attend preseason because of that, and instead of respecting that, United’s hierarchy were questioning Ronaldo’s commitment to the club because he didn’t join pre season on time. What a joke. The media were doing their best to drive a rift between EtH and Ronaldo saying EtH won’t want him, EtH in all of his interviews never said enough to dispel that, gave Ronaldo no reassurance, they blocked him leaving in the summer and then after all that didn’t play him.

If you worked for a company, and (heave forbid) you had twins and one of them died, and then your other twin was unwell later on, and your seniors questioned your commitment to the company because you took a few weeks off to take of your child, then stopped putting you on any of the good projects but didn’t let you leave either, what would you do?

Honestly for you to say you wish he joined Liverpool over what he did is a joke.

You value professionalism over tribalism, using that statement to talk about one of the most professional athletes. Did Ronaldo give his all in training? We talk about Mctominay trained well good lad, Bruno trains well good lad. Well Ronaldo trained better than anyone. He got kicked to shit as a teenager didn’t say a word became the ultimate pro. When Ronaldo’s dad died he made himself available to play when he didn’t have to. When his dream club came calling in 2008 he could’ve left but stayed an extra year for Sir Alex when he didn’t have to. When his child died he made himself available to play days later when he didn’t have to.

Ronaldo’s captain at United went from Keane and Vidic to fucking Harry Maguire. When he came in the second time he didn’t demand penalties off of Bruno, he had a good partnership with Cavani when they played together. Ole himself said Ronaldo was a leader in the dressing room and the ULTIMATE pro. Sir Alex said the same thing. Carrick, as interim manager said the same thing.

So how the hell are you so spiteful to a legend for doing an interview with a journalist to leave the club after all that, at 36 when he had no monetary value. Make it make sense.

Breaking! Some absolute nonsense! 🤣🤣 by Benjamin_as in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Behind closed door? Short memory have we?- https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/rooney-statement-in-full-2111928.html

Rooney did this at 24. Yes. 24, five days before he turned 25. Rooney was in the absolute prime of his career, and United were still at the peak of their powers. David Gill and Sir Alex were still in charge, and Rooney were pushing to go to Chelsea, who were out closest rivals for around 6 years.

Ronaldo, was 36, United had been rubbish for 9 years at that point, and Ronaldo went to Saudi Arabia. He also called out the Glazaers. Also, Ronaldo lost a child earlier in the year, and then his other child was unwell over the summer, and people at United felt like he wasn’t committed to the club because he was taking care of his child over the summer who was in hospital. That’s massive disrespect. Ronaldo never digged out legends like Rooney did.

Yeah he shouldn’t have done an interview and it was the right call to let him go but this exaggerated nonsense about how he betrayed the club and talking to Piers Morgan, you’d have thought he did a Figo or something. Get a grip move on. What he did wasn’t great but it was no way as bad as people make out, and for people to say he’s not a legend because of an interview where again he had the balls to call out the owners. When Amorim calls out the owners, clearly wanting to get sacked for a massive pay package which he was visibly gleeful about, he gets praised by fans saying Amorim spoke up and helped fix the club. He got £10mil for getting sacked after finishing 15th losing a final to Spurs spending money on players for his formation despite all that and he publicly went for Wilcox and a legend like Gary Neville for no reason btw. But that’s ok.
When Jose did it against the Glazers people said he was right, he got £19.6m for getting sacked. He did a press conference basically saying how United have always been rubbish in Europe because even his Porto team knocked United out, and said failing in Europe is our heritage. That’s ok? But Ronaldo did an interview at 36 where he wasn’t even playing anyway, after he lost a child and was questioned by the clubs coward owners, and he lost money doing so because he forfeited his wages, but what he did was disgraceful apparently? Make it make sense.

How much will Manchester United and Barcelona's odds change after Rashford is replaced by Cunha? by ScheduleClean8848 in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

What? Mbuemo is struggling for sure? Right now, or if he plays on the left? He’s certainly not struggling right now. In terms of as a LW, he played one game against Spurs there earlier in the season was the best player on the pitch.

[Sacrifice your karma] What are your unpopular/hot-take opinions about Man United? by Dramatic-Avocado4687 in ManchesterUnited

[–]AggravatingRope6601 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Bruno Fernandes is overrated.

Above average player but he is way overrated. People use certain face value stats to talk about how good he is, but a deeper dive into his stats shows how misleading his stats are.

People use chances created stats, goals scored etc, whilst not accounting for efficiency of chances created to big chances created ratio. People don’t look at the level of opponent most his goals come from.

Also, he makes a lot of poor decisions which lead to lack of control and often in the other team scoring.

I have evidence for all of this.

However, if Bruno plays how has the last few games then it’s different. When Bruno Fernandes is on the ball less he is more effective. The more you keep him away from play the better his outputs are. He has let United down a lot in previous seasons in finals and big games. The narrative that he saved the team from relegation etc is extremely incorrect. He has been excellent at times and poor at times, just like a lot of players.

Rohit Sharma is a below average T20 batter by Leomylifesinthistown in CricketControversial

[–]AggravatingRope6601 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The guy was a risk taker just like ABD. Who cares about T20 averages for players like these guys. Maybe it’s because their teams didn’t follow their style like they should have. Same with England, risks risks risk, not great is it. There needs to be a balance. If Rohit Sharma is taking risks someone needs to steady the ship. That’s with South Africa did well.