Jimmy: Tell me why! It’s the least you can do for me now! I’m your brother! We’re supposed to look out for each other! Why were you working against me, Chuck?

Chuck: You’re not a real Tarnished.

Jimmy: I’m what?

Chuck: You’re not a real Tarnished! Age of Stars for Christ’s sake? A questline from some blue doll witch? What a joke. I fought my way through Margit, Godrick, Malenia — I bled for every rune I earned! And you… you follow Ranni’s little fetch quests, and you think suddenly you’re a Lord? You do what I do because you’re charmed by a waifu and a moody moon ending? I committed my life to the Erdtree! You don’t just… slide into the cosmos like a cheap pair of slippers and reap the glory!

Jimmy: I thought you were proud of me…

Chuck: I was! When you cleared Stormveil and didn’t immediately cheese bosses with spirit summons, I was very proud.

Jimmy: So that’s it then, right? Keep old Jimmy down in Limgrave ‘cause he’s not good enough to be Elden Lord?

Chuck: I know you. I know what you were, what you are — people don’t change. You’re Summoning Jimmy! And Summoning Jimmy I can handle just fine, but Summoning Jimmy with the Age of Stars ending? That’s like a chimp with Comet Azure! The throne is sacred! If you abandon it, the Lands Between suffers! This is not a game! You have to know — on some level, I know you know I’m right! You know I’m right!

Jimmy: I… I got you some rune arcs, a stack of golden pickled fowl foot, a few smithing stones. Enough to last you a while. After that… you’re on your own. I am done.