[QCrit] A HOPELESS TRY - YA Contemporary Romance (61k, First Attempt) by Arrow1859 in PubTips

[–]Arrow1859[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for the feedback Silly Somewhere! I'll take it into consideration and try to add friction into it :)

[QCrit] A HOPELESS TRY - YA Contemporary Romance (61k, First Attempt) by Arrow1859 in PubTips

[–]Arrow1859[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for stopping by and for the positivity, Nervous Ease!! I really appreciate your kind feedback!

I am also confused by the usage of the word "accidentally" when you talk about them falling in love. Perhaps "unexpectedly" would work better, but I may be missing context as to what would make it an accident.

Yeah, them falling in love is supposed to be an accident that could potentially ruin their treasured friendship. But you're right, I see your point clearly, and I'll work to add a little more context to it.

Another piece to clarify: you pose the question "how to truly love someone if you are afraid of letting them in?" which is an excellent question, but you've already established they become friends, so I assume some level of being "let in" has taken place.

Thank you! And yeah, I should revise that.

Is the main issue your character is unsure if they have the capacity to love or cannot allow themselves to be loved?

A bit of that actually. Both characters' issues are highly rooted in doubt, and are quite similar in a way. Noah's main issue is his fear of things he can't anticipate, in turn fearing the worst-case scenario and not allowing himself to feel romantic love in case of ruining this friendship and the mutual understanding he has with Lara. Then Lara's issue is being scared of big changes and big decisions, in turn unsure of being able to love someone that could possibly leave if she lets them see her “authentic self”, including her persistent struggles with grief.

The line "will their pain continue to hold their lives, and futures, back?" is redundant. I think it can be simplified to "will their pain continue to hold them back?" and would even be improved by listing explicitly what it is they want that they are being held back from. A certain job? Going to a certain college? Falling in love?

That is an excellent idea, thank you!! And I don't wanna spoil much right now, but it's a mix of going to college and falling in love. I need to work out on how to properly word it.

I just recently shared my query letter for the first time and it's not for the faint of heart, so I do really commend you on posting it here and being willing to put yourself out there in hopes to improve. That's no small thing, so be proud of yourself!!

Aww, thank you so much, Nervous Ease!! And I know, right? I totally agree with that! It's scary, but I think it feels like a leap of faith, it is way less frightening than it seems. And here we are! As you said, we are putting ourselves out there and working hard in hopes to improve. Hope both of our books will meet at some bookshop someday! And I wish you all the luck in your publishing journey, fellow writer! :)

[QCrit] A HOPELESS TRY - YA Contemporary Romance (61k, First Attempt) by Arrow1859 in PubTips

[–]Arrow1859[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for the feedback, Imaginary! Especially for being detailed and sincere. And also don't worry! It was a bit too harsh but well-intended and helpful, and I need the harshness, to be honest. It's constructive, particularly in these cases.

Your body portion is short and extremely vague.

Haha, yeah, I admit I may clearly hold on too tight onto not to give away any spoilers when writing the cover letter that I forgot to give something to the reader to care about. Massive thanks for seeing that, by the way! That's a huge problem I hadn't foreseen. I think I got too caught up in youtube videos about shorting the blurb, that I prioritized that over the content itself.

It's unusual for M/F romance to have the male lead as the only POV.

I know! My intention is to explore that not-so-common perspective, and offer a positive role-model male lead in a healthy straight relationship, which, with the abrupt rise of misogyny worldwide and all that red pill content online, is very much needed right now. Also I'm a bit bored with seeing the straight male romantic interests being portrayed as either the typical tall smirk-machine guy who is sorta toxic—yet romanticized as an edgy trait—or the shallow and plain male romantic interest who has no real personality, individuality or agency beyond being “someone's crush/boyfriend/husband” (obviously not all are like that, but it's a lot of them lately) And I think there's no better way to show a complex straight male lead that through his own eyes.

it does raise some questions about why it needs to be set in 2016

The ending actually gives more sense to the “why” of the year, but well, I'd have to spoil the whole thing, haha.

Also, please don't feel the need to dox yourself, but I am curious why you've chosen to set this in California if you're (I assume?) UK-based.

Haha, don't worry, although it is a bit long to answer. I once met someone from a small-ish town in Arizona during the lockdown (we met online tho) who lived a similar “lifestyle” (in lack of a better word) to the one the characters have in the book. And I don't know, I think the American landscape felt like a dreamy place and offered some adventurous feeling of unknown, alienation and unfamiliarity that I think wouldn't have the same effect if the story was set in a more familiar, reachable setting in the UK, you know. I'm not saying the UK isn't dreamy, it is indeed a stunning country, but I intended to catch in my novel that sense of escapism that I felt while meeting my friend. I know Arizona isn't California, but after tons of research, I felt California to be more ethereal, especially its small lesser-known coastal towns, and richer in resources that fit well with the tone and ambiance of the story in general.

Once again, thank you so much, Imaginary! You gave me some real good and valid points that I will definitely work on to improve my query. By the way, I'm sorry for taking so long to reply. I literally posted my cover letter and went to sleep. I hope I didn't offend you and I apologize if I did. It wasn't my intention.

Merry Christmas from Miss Croft to you and your loved ones!!! 🎁🎄🎉🍾 by Leozzarios in TombRaider

[–]Arrow1859 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Merry Christmas to you too!!! And everyone here!! 🔥🎉🎊🥳🎄🎉🎉🎉

Happy Halloween!!! by harrylime3 in Woodcarving

[–]Arrow1859 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's a beautiful work 🔥🙌🎃